Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

These Politicians are Playing in Our Faces
Imani Nile
10 Oct 2023
Images of all the presidents since Ronald Regan

Joe Biden had a moment of truth when he promised the oligarchs that nothing would fundamentally change if he became president. He kept his promise, and so will all those who come after him unless there is fundamental systemic change in this country. 

Imagine waking up in the morning as a child, running into the kitchen, grabbing your favorite bowl of cereal, and enjoying a few minutes of sugary bliss. If your favorite cereal was Froot Loops, you may have noticed the different colors of each of those delicious loops. The various colors may have led you to believe they are all different flavors, but they aren’t. As children, with our child-like minds and exuberance, many of us were fooled into believing we were eating lemon, lime, orange, cherry, etc. But now we know that was a mere illusion. 

This illusion is unfortunately not unlike the current state of politics in the United States. The capitalist white supremacist settler colonial state subjects the masses to indoctrination so strong it keeps their minds in a perpetual state of child-like understanding of the political forces in this country. This locks us into political stasis where the masses vote for the same candidates over and over again every 2-4 years, in slightly different colors. 

We are presented with two standard options: red or blue. Sometimes we get a candidate that is a shade of maroon, or fire engine red. Maybe an indigo, or cobalt. Every once in a while, progressives or leftists who haven't left the Democratic Party get what they consider to be an anomaly, someone who appears to challenge the party's political hegemony. The truth is that these people still act within their assigned boundaries. If they step out of line they get spanked and told to shape up.

The more troubling part is how they still believe that the Democrat blue and Republican red are functionally different. That they serve separate purposes. We hear an annoyingly common refrain, "It's ridiculous to say they are exactly the same", and “We need to hold off the ‘fascists’ in the GOP!” But these arguments miss the real issue at hand. 

All these politicians – the President and his administration, Congress, state governors, state legislators – are part of the capitalist class or have thrown their hats in the ring with them. They all work to serve the interests of the ruling elite. Even the more “progressive” among them only have goals that amount to occasionally tossing the working class a bone as they leave us fighting over scraps.

They are committed to the maintenance of their positions within that class and the protection of the class itself. The "differences” amount to political infighting, not a battle to "save our democracy". The clashes we see are analogous to family arguments over the dinner table or the drunk uncle taking a swing at his brother at the family reunion. At the end of the day, if someone outside the family threatens them, they will stand together and close ranks. No one else crosses the family.

They ride together. They die together. Capitalists for life. 

We’ve been sold sparkly lies and gobbledygook every presidential and congressional election, with buffoonery and chicanery in between. Their lack of substance goes hand-in-hand with a commitment to brand themselves as leaders who will turn this ship around, with the help of fancy (and expensive) public relations firms. This PR strategy is evidenced in the campaign slogans of the last three US presidents: Barack Obama (2008) – “Change We Can Believe In”/Yes We Can", Barack Obama (2012) – "Forward", Donald Trump (2016) – "Make America Great Again”, Joe Biden (2020) – "Our Best Days Still Lie Ahead".

These slogans all appeal to the people who look fondly upon a past that never existed or hopefully toward a future that will never materialize. Not one of them expresses the realities of our society during the terms of each president. Obama demolished Libya to install a puppet regime. He exponentially escalated the use of drone strikes post the George Bush Jr. presidency, killing U.S. citizens and children as collateral damage. Donald Trump led four years of outright bigotry and horrifying anti-immigration policy, went through two impeachments, and left with a grand finale of an insurrection.

Biden, our current disappointment of a President, managed to flop on everything he promised to do. Student debt relief? Flop. Build Back Better? Flop. Addressing climate change? Flop. Legalizing Abortion? Big Flop. Biden has spent $135 billion on Ukraine while people here starve. Now, he is coordinating the invasion of Haiti using Black and Brown nations and people as a cover. Are we building back better on the backs of our Haitian brothers and sisters? On the bodies of the Ukrainian working class being slaughtered in a proxy war generously funded by the US?

In the face of the Republican Party’s determination to plunge the country into the abyss, it is disingenuous to say the Democratic Party is an “opposition party”. They are doing everything but that. We have Jamaal Bowman clowning on TikTok, laughing at Trump, and pretending to support unions, but voting against a railroad worker’s strike. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is doing Instagram Lives pretending to be fun and down to earth as she helps recruit our children into the military. 

A true opposition party would fight tooth and nail to counter anything that threatens the working class domestically and internationally. Instead, they hold hands as they skip happily toward nuclear war and climate catastrophe to protect their class interests.

These people take us for a joke. They sell us thinly veiled lies and poorly executed misdirections. They rely on the indoctrination by the media, the education system they defunded, and the perpetual crisis of being poor and overworked to keep us from fully seeing the game. They play in our faces and most of the working class is too tired, sick, hungry, poor, stressed, and/or undereducated to worry about fighting the duopoly. 

They tell us to vote to protect our futures but persecute us for demanding the right to have a say in what that future looks like. They chastise 40 percent of the population for not standing in line for six hours in gerrymandered districts to vote on their work or school days, because it is the "most important election of our lifetime." Every major election for the last 30 years, at least, has been the most important election of our lifetime. If every election is the election that determines whether the nation will plummet to its doom, maybe (and stay with me here) our electeds are doing something wrong? Maybe they are fascists in progressive clothing pulling the same party trick over and over right before our eyes.

If a fascist plays in your face, the only reasonable response is to punch them in theirs. 

It is not only reasonable, it is the right thing to do. It is our obligation to politically strike those who place themselves in positions of political leadership and sit upon their ever-growing pile of gold as they gaslight and lie to us, steal from us, and leave us for dead.

We have long reached a point where socialism, led by Black and other oppressed working-class people, is the only way. With the presidential election coming up next year, we need to make a clear statement – that we won’t stay on this hamster wheel. More than that, we have to step up our efforts to engage ourselves and others in on-the-ground community organizing. 

We can’t continue to pretend that the duopoly holds anything for us. We need to show people how these politicians, regardless of affiliation, got us messed up. We’re doing working-class people a disservice by continuing to funnel them into the Democratic Party because we are afraid to take the leap and use our energy and votes more wisely. We can’t support those who would do nothing more than offer “thoughts and prayers” after we perish in the next climate catastrophe, with the justification that “we just need to get this guy out of the way”. Donald Trump, or whatever other conservative boogeyman, isn’t the only one we need to get out of the way. We have to let go of the last vestiges of liberalism and hope that the Dems will offer us some protection or that they will stand in the way of our descent into a complete fascist police state.

It’s not going to happen.

Just like Froot Loops, the differences y’all see only go so far. Red or blue, a capitalist is still a capitalist. A fascist is still a fascist.

Imani Nile is the assistant to BAR's Executive Editor and a proud member of the Black Alliance for Peace NYC/NJ. She works in movement communications and media.

US Politics
Joe Biden
Barack Obama
Donald Trump
Democrats
Republicans
Fascism

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
Biden's Fate and Israel's Sadistic Revenge
21 May 2025
Israel is starving Gazans to death and continuing its bombing attacks on civilians.
Natalia Marques
New Jersey Fights Mass Deportations at the Newly-Minted Delaney Hall Detention Center
21 May 2025
The Trump administration opens a new ICE detention center in New Jersey’s biggest city and a hub for immigrant communities, earning a bold resp
Trump and Harris
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
Corruption, Lies, Biden's Health and Trump's Victory
14 May 2025
The same corporate media talking heads who told us to ignore Biden’s failin
Raymond Nat Turner, BAR poet-in-residence
DOGE— Department Of Grifter Enrichment
07 May 2025
“Empathy is the bane of western civilization.” 
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
Graylan Hagler: Capitulation Masquerading as Political Thought
30 April 2025
Liberals continue to condemn anyone who didn’t support Kamala Harris and the latest iteration of neo-liberal treachery.
Anthony Karefa Rogers-Wright
Neo-Kautskyism: Exposing the Bernie/AOC “Fight Oligarchy” Tour de Farce
23 April 2025
Lenin called out Kautsky’s fake socialism more than a century ago—today, Bernie and AOC are playing the same game, trading radical change for l
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
Cory Booker, Confused Liberals, Obama's Reappearance, and the Dangers of a Fake Movement
09 April 2025
Any “movement” that leads protest back to the Democratic Party is, by
Hands Off protest
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
HANDS OFF NATO? Not Palestine? Who got the memo?
09 April 2025
The Democrats’ HANDS OFF rallies included “HANDS OFF NATO” and
Oliver Robinson
Trump Terror, Complicit Local Leadership, and the Assault Against Southeast D.C.
09 April 2025
Donald Trump’s new “Safe and Beautiful” task force is little more than a thinly veiled assault on Black working-class communities in Southeast
Alan MacLeod
Betar: the Far-Right Hate Group Helping Trump Deport Israel’s Critics
09 April 2025
Betar U.S., a far-right Zionist organization with ties to violent extremism, is quietly shaping Trump administration policy, compiling lists of

More Stories


  • Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
    Biden's Fate and Israel's Sadistic Revenge
    21 May 2025
    Israel is starving Gazans to death and continuing its bombing attacks on civilians. Israel also specializes in personal revenge, targeting men, women, and children who might be the subject of…
  • Editors, The Black Agenda Review
    ESSAY: Towards Lasting Peace, Shirley Graham DuBois, 1970
    21 May 2025
    Shirley Graham Du Bois on the liberation of Palestine.
  • Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
    Propaganda Watch: Kagame Is Not Traoré
    21 May 2025
    A recurring social media trope casts Rwandan President Paul Kagame as a defiant African hero, like Burkina Faso’s Ibrahim Traoré, resisting the West’s dictates, but nothing could be further from the…
  • Jon Jeter
    In DC, A New ‘Mayor 1 Percent” This Time in Blackface
    21 May 2025
    Muriel Bowser is proving that Black faces in high places don’t break systems, they grease them. While slashing wages for tipped workers and handing billionaires stadium deals, D.C.’s mayor is the…
  • Anthony Karefa Rogers-Wright
    Temerity, Tartuffery, and Toxic Identity Reductionism…the Latest Democrat Party Hoggwash
    21 May 2025
    The Democratic Party would rather silence critics like Hogg than fix its own rot. Their reliance on Black Misleaders to do the dirty work exposes once again that the Democrats care more about power…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us