Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.: Sheepdogging and Liberal Fantasy
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
31 May 2023
Robert F. Kennedy Jr.:  Sheepdogging and Liberal Fantasy
Image: Twitter @RobertKennedyJr

There is an understandable yearning for a progressive president. But like dreams of happily ever after endings, the fantasy is just that.

In 2015, Black Agenda Report co-founder Bruce Dixon coined the term “sheepdog” to describe the role that Bernie Sanders would play in the 2016 presidential campaign. Dixon presciently said, “Bernie's job is to warm up the crowd for Hillary, herding activist energies and the disaffected left back into the Democratic fold one more time. Bernie aims to tie up activist energies and resources till the summer of 2016 when the only remaining choice will be the usual lesser of two evils.” The word stuck and since that time the question is rightly asked whether a particular democratic challenger is serious about getting the nomination or is merely a sheepdog who will herd supporters back into the hands of their party’s oligarchy.

That question arises again now that Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. has announced his presidential campaign. Kennedy obviously has the advantage of name recognition, and he isn’t shy about making frequent references to “my uncle” and “my father.” Yet he is attractive to leftists in the party because he is willing to take positions in opposition to its established orthodoxy. He does make the obligatory references to Russia’s “brutal invasion” of Ukraine but he also points out what no one in the Democratic Party will say, that the war was provoked by U.S. actions and he calls the billions of dollars in allocations to the Ukrainian government a “money laundering operation for the military industrial complex.” 

Yet Kennedy also falls back into line if pressured. He said that the CIA assassinated his uncle John F. Kennedy, and he points out the many CIA interventions around the world as a practice he would end as president, but he backtracks if criticized, making a lie out of his pronouncements. “The majority of people working at the CIA are good, patriotic people committed to their missions and the law. My own daughter-in-law was a field agent, and she is among the bravest people I have known.”

He certainly got the zionist message about Israel. Kennedy praised musician Roger Waters for his opposition to the war in Ukraine but then deleted his comment on twitter because Waters also opposes Israeli apartheid. For good measure he added meaningless blather about the “aspirations of the Palestinian people.” After being called out when he ran for cover, he then deleted his comments which rescinded his first comment. 

There is another issue aside from Kennedy’s willingness to back pedal when criticized for taking the positions he claims to run against. Will his supporters end up like those who worked for Jesse Jackson, Dennis Kucinich, or Bernie Sanders, who believed in their candidate only to be told that they had to support Mondale or Dukakis or Kerry or Clinton or Biden? One must ask, what is the point of going out on a limb yet again when history gives a strong indication of how this campaign will end? 

The selective amnesia of many Kennedy supporters indicates another problem with what passes for left politics in this country. People here have been so thoroughly indoctrinated about the value of electoral politics that they believe it is the only way to bring about the changes they want to see. The end result is the search for a savior, the belief that we can vote our way out of a situation created by the oligarchy which controls both wings of the duopoly. It is comforting to think that the right president would end capitalist exploitation and imperialism but such a belief, while understandable, doesn’t hold water.

Would the military industrial complex suddenly disappear if Kennedy were president? Would the democrats and republicans who are bought off by big oil, big pharma, big agriculture, big healthcare, and other powerful interests suddenly throw off the shackles they happily accepted? Would their patrons allow them to do so even if they were so inclined? The answer to all of these questions is a resounding, “No.” Both parties are run by capitalists who have not gone to a lot of trouble to maintain their hold on the system only to give it all up because some democrats can’t end their habit of engaging in wishful thinking. 

Robert F. Kennedy Jr. takes positions that need to be heard. It is good that a presidential candidate opposes U.S. interventions around the world and pledges to end the censorship that the state and big tech carry out. But there’s no savior, just the hard work of mobilizing left movements. Kennedy speaks of the need for a "peaceful revolution." It isn't clear that revolutions can be peaceful, but they certainly won't come from U.S. presidential politics. 

The question is the same. It doesn't change every four years. How do we mobilize against interests that won't be placated, whose imperatives are antithetical to human needs? They don't care if leftists want to believe that Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. can win the Democratic Party nomination and become president. They won't be wished away. 

Margaret Kimberley is the author of Prejudential: Black America and the Presidents. You can support her work on Patreon  and also find it on the Twitter and Telegram platforms. She can be reached via email at margaret.kimberley(at)blackagendareport.com.

Robert F. Kennedy Jr
2024 election
sheepdog

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

RFK, Jr. Exposes His Right-Wing Tendencies Again, This Time On Abortion
Jacqueline Luqman
RFK, Jr. Exposes His Right-Wing Tendencies Again, This Time On Abortion
16 August 2023
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. made and then tried to walk-back comments which supported banning abortion in some circumstances.
Trump Indictments Subvert the Legal and Political System
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
Trump Indictments Subvert the Legal and Political System
14 June 2023
The recent indictments of former president Donald Trump are political acts intended to keep him from becoming president again.
Green Party Run for Dr. Cornel West
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
Green Party Run for Dr. Cornel West
14 June 2023
Dr.

More Stories


  • Black Agenda Radio September 22, 2023
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Black Agenda Radio September 22, 2023
    22 Sep 2023
    U.S. hostility towards China, the Beloved Community and the effort to end violence, and partisan gerrymandering and its impact on voting rights.
  • U.S. Hostility to China Strengthens Multipolarity
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    U.S. Hostility to China Strengthens Multipolarity
    22 Sep 2023
    Danny Haiphong is a long time Black Agenda Report contributing editor. He is now the host of his own Youtube channel.
  • Ending Violence with the Beloved Community in Chicago
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Ending Violence with the Beloved Community in Chicago
    22 Sep 2023
    Orion Meadows is a non-violence trainer with Institute for Nonviolence Chicago.
  • Partisan Gerrymandering and Voting Rights
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Partisan Gerrymandering and Voting Rights
    22 Sep 2023
    Michael Li is Senior Counsel in the Democracy Program at the Brennan Center for Justice.
  • Why Barack Obama Can't Shut Up
    Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
    Why Barack Obama Can't Shut Up
    20 Sep 2023
    Barack Obama devastated millions of people all over the world and speaks of his actions as if they were committed by someone else. It is a masterful performance by a man committed to deception.
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us