Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Alicia Keys Hits a Not So Strange Note
Bill Quigley
23 Apr 2008
🖨️ Print Article

Alicia Keys Hits a Not So Strange Note

by Mel Reeves

"Artists don't really
lead movements but respond and reflect them."

KeysGOOD
Singer Alicia Keys got herself in a little hot water last
week when she said in a magazine
interview
that Gangsta Rap was a ploy to "convince black people to kill
each other," and that the initiator of the plot was the US government. While
many folks have had knee-jerk reactions about what they think she said,it is
important to look at the feelings she provoked, as well as to take a longer
look at what Gangster Rap exposed and what the government did or not do to
eliminate the conditions from which the genre arose.

Most black folks as well as astute outside observers will
probably point out that you don't have to have a ploy to get black people to
kill one another, or to hate on one another. 
That was neatly taken care of by the large reservoir of self hate,
accumulated through a history of chattel slavery, unofficial (wage) slavery,
legal segregation, officially ignored and unofficially sanctioned terrorism,
rape of our lands and our bodies and a constant sense of second-placeness and
inferiority that would have made a lesser people fold their tents.
Nevertheless, the larger society has had enough of us complaining about racism
and the impact it has on our daily lives.

Keys' critics demand that she shut up and sing. I find it
interesting that a vast assortment of stars can express their opinions, but
when a young black singer with an anti-government position practices one of her
guaranteed rights she is told to stifle herself.

"You don't have to have a
ploy to get black people to kill one another."

While the government didn't conspire to create Gangsta Rap,
it played a monstrous role in creating the conditions that produced the genre.

Young people were rapping about their experiences, or their
imagined experiences, which is at bottom what most art depicts. So, young
people in the poorest and most rundown sections of urban America turned to the
negative yet nurturing influence of gangs. They witnessed those who played by
the rules and who were making the best of a bad situation having their burdens
increased by low wages, discriminatory hiring practices, discriminatory loan
practices, redlining and glass ceilings. Having found legitimacy wanting, they
said, "no thanks."

This was not the result of a direct government conspiracy,
but the causes and effects are rather clear.

Who among us can argue that the violence, misogyny,
blatant materialism and narcissism that is manifested in much of Hip Hop is not
vexing to our spirits? It has popularized gangs and gang culture, drugs and
drug dealing, pimps and pimp culture and even prison life and prison culture.
It has glorified whores and whoring, with its fascination with strippers and
strip clubs and has pornified and objectified women. It reduces relationships
to a soulless effort to obtain sex and money. It has exacerbated homophobia. It
has taken playing the dozens and put downs, to a completely different and self
defeating level. It has made revenge and revenge killing a matter of honor,
rather than what it really is, a demonstration of weakness.

"Gangsta Rap reduces
relationships to a soulless effort to obtain sex and money."

In another interview, Keys expanded on her Gangsta Rap
thoughts:

"The point that I was trying to make was that the term was
oversloganized by some of the media causing reactions that were not always
positive. Many of the 'gangsta rap' lyrics articulate the problems of the
artists' experiences and I think all of us, including our leaders, could be
doing more to address these problems including drugs, gang violence, crime, and
other related social issues."

If we are honest we know that she has a valid point. What
else were the kids going to rap about, the experiences of suburban whites? They
sounded a warning and we responded by trying to get rid of the symptom rather
than the cause. There were groups that sprang up (remember C. Delores Tucker)
and Congressional Hearings insisting that the music be banned rather than
ameliorating the causes and conditions that produced the music. Our pain and
public humiliation was good entertainment.

Hip Hop didn't start out as a negative cultural and
political force. Cool Herc, Kurtis Blow, Melle Mel, Run DMC, were putting our
story to music and rhymes. Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five wrapped our
plight neatly in "The Message." And then came the more serious KRS-One, Chuck
D, NWA, Public Enemy who followed in the footsteps of the earlier musical
prophets Gil Scott Heron, the Last Poets and the Watts Prophets.

"Our pain and public
humiliation was good entertainment."

But Keys' attempt to speak out is a reminder that artists
don't really lead movements but respond and reflect them, much as Gangster Rap
reflects the environment from which it springs. Our having to rely on the young
songstress to speak a truth that should have long been spoken is definitely not
a good indicator of black political progress. But our collective hats should be
tipped to her for trying to bring clarity and remind us of our (correctable)
failures.

Mel Reeves is an activist living in Miami. He
can be contacted at mellaneous19@yahoo.com.

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


More Stories


  • BAR Book Forum: Liat Ben-Moshe’s “Decarcerating Disability”
    Roberto Sirvent, BAR Book Forum Editor
    BAR Book Forum: Liat Ben-Moshe’s “Decarcerating Disability”
    26 Aug 2020
    Disability studies looks at disability as an identity and culture and not as a deficit to be corrected.
  • BAR Book Forum: “Black Study and Abolition”
    Hilary Malson
    BAR Book Forum: “Black Study and Abolition”
    26 Aug 2020
    The author examines literature that looks to sites of struggle to find the seeds of an alternative, more just future.
  • Obama, Harris and the Ruse of Racial Representation
    Nelson Maldonado-Torres 
    Obama, Harris and the Ruse of Racial Representation
    26 Aug 2020
    Racial liberalism attempts to shape the perspectives of communities of color through narrow ideas of national belonging, Manifest Destiny, and the American Dream.
  • Federal Judge Tackles Police Immunity Law
    Marjorie Cohn
    Federal Judge Tackles Police Immunity Law
    26 Aug 2020
    The Black judge listed the injustices of “qualified immunity,” which allows police and other government officials to escape liability for their law breaking.
  • COVID-19’s Toll on People of Color Is Worse Than We Knew
    The Marshall Project
    COVID-19’s Toll on People of Color Is Worse Than We Knew
    26 Aug 2020
    Some coronavirus deaths, especially early on, were mistakenly attributed to other causes.
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us