Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

Letters from Our Readers
by Jahan Choudhry, Comments Editor
07 Apr 2021

In "On Anarchism and Black Revolution" Peter James Hudson examines the historical roots of critiques of anarchism and its relationship to Black liberation movements.

Johnnie Lewis writes:

“I believe on reading Leon Trotsky’s History of the Russian Revolution, one finds that during the actual revolution and the civil war and imperialist invasion afterwards, anarchists were incorporated by the thousands into the new Communist Party and into the government, including the Red Army, as were ‘left’ Social Revolutionaries, another strand of anarchism.”

Robert Blandford writes:

“The article, in my mind, engenders the question, how do we establish conditions to abolish the nation-state short of dictatorship of the working class? Many of the positive characteristics and forms of struggle that need to be developed or nurtured ,according to Lorenzo Ervin’s thought, are in fact already situated in Marxist theory and practice. I see nothing new in communes (Black or multi-national), direct democracy, autonomous community councils, all of which, including more, that have already been articulated within the Marxist-Leninist conceptual framework. Moreover, Ervin’s resistance to the nation-state is justified when he discusses it as the center around which liberation struggles were satellites or proxies, but which does not give the full picture of the problem of unity and support against international imperialism. Admittedly, bureaucratic insurgency even within the socialist state was and is a problem, but that does not rule out the necessity of practical work in the fight for socialism and communism. It is facile to cherry pick among ideology and espouse a new direction for the Black liberation struggle that has not been hammered out on the anvils of experience and context, but the best features of anarchy thrive, and are nestled within the Black revolutionary perspective, which adheres to Marx’s analysis of capitalism and anti-capitalist struggle.”

The struggle to develop ideological clarity means the struggle to find a correct ideology. The history of successful movements holds the key to differentiating between correct and incorrect ideologies.

Jahan Choudhry is Comments Editor for Black Agenda Report.  He is an organizer with the Saturday Free School based in Philadelphia, PA.

COMMENTS?

Please join the conversation on Black Agenda Report's Facebook page at http://facebook.com/blackagendareport

Or, you can comme  nt by emailing us at [email protected]

Comments

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
21 April 2021
This week pro-Zionist censorship and police brutality were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
31 March 2021
This week the U.S. state’s propaganda and the Black elite were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
10 March 2021
This week Pan Africanism and the Black Panther Party were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
03 March 2021
This week the blackout in Texas, the recent film on Fred Hampton, and Democracy Now’s international coverage were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
24 February 2021
This week you discussed the struggle against the dollar and neocolonialism.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
17 February 2021
This week color-blindness on the left and the Black Misleadership Class were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
10 February 2021
This week you discussed the multilayer crisis facing American people.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry, BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
03 February 2021
The federal government’s stimulus payments and the role of black police officers were on your minds.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
27 January 2021
This week our readers talked about the weakness of the U.S. left, the storming of the Capitol, and the crisis of U.S. imperialism.
Letters from Our Readers
Jahan Choudhry BAR Comments Editor
Letters from Our Readers
20 January 2021
This week the uprising in Washington and Du Bois’s writings on the Soviet Union were on your mind.

More Stories


  • African Liberation Day Special Issue
    BAR Editors
    African Liberation Day Special Issue
    25 May 2022
    The Black Agenda Report team gives special emphasis to African Liberation Day, which is celebrated on May 25.
  • Capitalism and Baby Formula
    Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
    Capitalism and Baby Formula
    25 May 2022
    The baby formula shortage is not a glitch in the system. It actually exemplifies everything that goes wrong when the profit motive rules. Capitalism can't ensure a food supply or anything else that…
  • African Liberation Day: Imamu Amiri Baraka, 1972
    Editors, The Black Agenda Review
    African Liberation Day: Imamu Amiri Baraka, 1972
    25 May 2022
    On this African Liberation Day, we revisit Amiri Baraka’s 1972 communiqué calling for Black people to struggle for Pan-African unity while also registering our anger at the “pathology and trait
  • US Threatens Ethiopia and Eritrea with Illegal “Legal Designation of Genocide”
    Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
    US Threatens Ethiopia and Eritrea with Illegal “Legal Designation of Genocide”
    25 May 2022
    The US is falsely accusing Ethiopia and Eritrea of hindering food aid and committing genocides in the ongoing war in Tigray.
  • Malcolm X and Ho Chi Minh Remind Us of the Roots of White Supremacy in the Aftermath of Buffalo Shooting
    Danny Haiphong, BAR Contributing Editor
    Malcolm X and Ho Chi Minh Remind Us of the Roots of White Supremacy in the Aftermath of Buffalo Shooting
    25 May 2022
    Malcolm X and Ho Chi Minh shared a birthday. They also shared an internationalist ideology, a commitment to liberation for all people, and a deep understanding of how racist structures operated…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us