Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Letters from BAR Readers This Week
Jahan Chowdhry, BAR Comments Editor
14 Oct 2018
🖨️ Print Article
war in syria
This week: Still more on the Supreme Court, Ajamu Baraka and Margaret Kimberley on the war in Syria,

“World War Dangers in Syria,” “Syria and the S-300s,” and “Democratic Fascism vs the Trump Kind” provoked strong feedback this week. Readers were interested in discussing matters related to imperial attacks on Syria and the role of Black voters in the Democratic Party.

In “World War Dangers in Syria” Margaret Kimberley analyses the risks of recent American and Israeli aggression against Syria.

Referring to Washington’s wars on Syria, Iraq, and Libya reader Bill Weldin writes:

“Of course, our white American rulers sought to crush these socialist success stories, just as Jefferson sought to destroy Haiti’s black success story with his US embargo of 1806. Now as then, our white rulers war in syriamaintained that the world must be made to believe that no alternative exists—because no alternative is allowed to exist—to predatory capitalism with its extremes of wealth, longevity, death during pregnancy, infant mortality, and the like. But while Gaddafi’s socialist Libya and Saddam’s socialist Iraq have now been replaced by US “failed states,” the people of Syria fight on. Because they see themselves as one people, the Syrian people—be they Sunni, Shiite, Christian, or Jew. Freedom of religion does that to people: it helps makes them a people.

"And so the Syrian people fought on as one people for their secular, socialist, religiously-free nation—the Syrian nation—for 4 long, increasingly hopeless years with mostly Soviet-era weapons against terrorists with advanced American weapons, backed by the US Air Force, until Putin finally overcame his personal bonds of affection for Israel, going back to childhood (which is an essay in itself), and entered the war on Syria’s side with a few dozen planes. That was enough to ensure that the multi-faith forces of the Syrian nation will eventually win—short of the white supremacists in Washington committing ground troops or going nuke!”

In “Syria and the S-300s: Re-Centering the People in Global Struggles for Power” columnist Ajamu Baraka works towards a people-centered analysis of the geopolitics of the Russia’s missile sales to Syria.

Wallace Nixon responds emphasizing the role of Israel:war in syria

“We now know something about Israel´s criminal behavior in the Middle East. However, few in the United States are aware of the criminal support and counseling Israel gives to police in many American cities. The same Israelis who murder and incarcerate children in Palestine and violate Syrian airspace whenever they want, killing civilians, do not have to answer for what they teach US policemen when they travel there for advanced training in things such as interrogation techniques and crowd control. Most important, blacks in the country feed at the Zionist hog trough and find it not wise to bite the hand that feeds them, but there are serious thinkers amongst us who dare to defy the enforced silence we see when it comes to Israeli crimes at home and abroad. Some time ago the city of Durham decided to discontinue sending their police officers to Israel to better learn how to murder poor people in minority communities. It was a commendable and just thing to do! How many black people know about this singular and necessary effort to eliminate barbaric behavior by police?”

“Democratic Fascism vs the Trump Kind” by Glen Ford argues that American fascism exists in both white Trumpism and its “diverse” Democratic Party adversaries who share the goals of austerity and endless war.

T. Davis replies:

Enjoyed the article and was very sympathetic with it. I did, however, find one phrase in it a painful expression of wishful thinking. To say that Blacks are ‘historically, the most left-leaning and peace-minded’ group ignores the reality of the present.

"As a white person I struggled to understand the overwhelming support of Blacks for Hillary Clinton as opposed to Bernie Sanders, the latter being remarkably more left-leaning domestically even if any foreign policy differences were obscured or not discussed. The only explanation I could conceive was that Blacks, being still basically an oppressed minority, are quick to attach themselves to supposed heroes as a gesture of hope.”

I suggest that this reader will find the answer to his inquiry in Glen’s piece, “Vector of Fear: Blacks and the Democratic Party” analyzing Black voting strategy in the 2016 election. As Ford wrote in February of that election year:

“Blacks are drawn into the jaws of the Democratic Party, not by ideological affinity, but in search of protection from the Republicans. This is an entirely different dynamic than an alignment based on thoughtful examination of political platforms. It’s not about picking a candidate or party that sees the world as most Black people do, from the left side of the spectrum, on matters of social justice and peace. Rather, the overarching objective is to choose a candidate from the Democratic wing of the Rich Man’s duopoly who is best equipped to defeat his or her Republican counterpart. Under these stilted circumstances, the Democratic candidate’s actual political positions become near-irrelevant to the Black primary voter, compared to the candidate’s perceived ability to win a national election. The question becomes, is the Democrat strong enough to beat back the latest offensive from the GOP? – which Black people perceive as an existential threat. In the grip of that mindset, the contestant that is richer, better connected to the party apparatus and more acceptable to masses of white voters is the better Black choice.”

We anticipate another week of thoughtful letters on pressing issues. The best of them will continue to be featured here.

Jahan Choudhry is Comments Editor for Black Agenda Report. He is an organizer with the Saturday Free School based in Philadelphia, PA. Reach him at jchoudhry(at)blackagendareport.com.

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


More Stories


  • Rally against sanctions
    Clau O'Brien Moscoso
    Peoples to Peoples Encounters: Venezuela’s Vice Minister of Foreign Affairs for North America In Dialogue with Local Organizations and Social Movements in New York
    14 Feb 2024
    Venezuela's Vide Minister of Foreign Affairs, Carlos Ron, recently met with representatives from various organizations and social movements to discuss the latest U.S. effort to destabilize the…
  • Haitian person holding their fist in the air at a protest
    MOLEGHAF
    MOLEGHAF: Public Statement on the Country's Situation
    14 Feb 2024
    MOLEGHAF released a statement calling for support of the Haitian masses mobilizing for popular sovereignty and vehemently rejects the continued attempts by the United States and the West to force a…
  • Revolt of 1811 path
    Abayomi Azikiwe
    African Emigration and the United States Civil War
    14 Feb 2024
    Through flight and rebellion, enslaved people created the conditions for their on liberation.
  • Press conference during the trial of three police officers
    Mireille Fanon Mendes France
    Does a trial mean justice? Questions asked at the end of Théodore Luhaka’s trial
    14 Feb 2024
    The brutal physical assault against Théodore Luhaka by three police officers, and their subsequent acquittal, is a heartbreaking example of the long relationship between the colonizer and the…
  • Joe Biden
    Tamara Nassar
    “Genocide Joe” sets the tone for US election year
    14 Feb 2024
    Protests have trailed Biden and others in his administration for months in response to the genocide in Gaza.
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us