Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

Judge Orders Release of Three 'Newburgh Four', Says FBI 'invented conspiracy'
Umar A Farooq
02 Aug 2023
Judge Orders Release of Three 'Newburgh Four', Says FBI 'invented conspiracy'
Image: The documentary "The Newburgh Sting"

The U.S. embarked on a spree of entrapments in the post-9/11 years. Informants were used against gullible and vulnerable people, most of them Black, in order to secure spurious convictions and make the case for more surveillance and for war. Three of the men known as the Newburgh Four were recently granted compassionate release after 14 years in prison. The same judge who sentenced them now says, "Nothing about the crimes of conviction was of defendants' doing. The FBI invented the conspiracy."

Originally published in Middle East Eye.

A US federal judge has ordered the release on compassionate grounds of three men convicted in a case that became known as the "Newburgh Four", in a severe rebuke of the FBI's use of an informant in an "unscrupulous" operation to persuade the men into committing a violent plot to blow up synagogues and shoot down National Guard planes.

In a scathing rebuke against the FBI, US District Judge Colleen McMahon said that the men - Laguerre Payen, Onta Williams, and David Williams - were "in reality, hapless, easily manipulated and penurious petty criminals".

The fourth individual, James Cromitie, did not seek compassionate release and is expected to serve until 2030. However, his lawyer told the Associated Press she plans to speak with him about pursuing similar action on his behalf.

McMahon's 28-page ruling, released on Thursday, went on to say that all four men were caught up in a 2009 plot that was driven by Shahed Hussain, a confidential informant described by the judge as "unsavory", and overzealous FBI agents.

The judge granted compassionate release to the three men and reduced their sentences to the time they have already served plus an additional 90 days, down from the original 25-year sentence imposed on the men in 2011.

"The real lead conspirator was the United States," McMahon wrote.

"Nothing about the crimes of conviction was of defendants' doing. The FBI invented the conspiracy."

The US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York and the FBI declined to comment on the ruling.

"While the FBI has consistently concocted 'terrorism' plots to entrap unsuspecting community members, this case was one of the most egregious and exploitative, for the reasons summarized by Judge McMahon," said Amith R Gupta, part of a group of lawyers representing Payen and the two Willamses, who are not related.

"The informant took advantage of extreme poverty and there was little to no evidence that our clients - rather than the informant - initiated any discussion about violent activity," Gupta told Middle East Eye.

He added that the case is an example of the US government's practice in which it "manufacture[s] terrorism threats at the expense of the most vulnerable members of our society in order to justify its still-ongoing war on terrorism".

'Trolling for terrorists'

Payen, Cromitie, and the Williamses were arrested in 2009 on charges including "conspiracy to use weapons of mass destruction". They were later convicted in 2011 and sentenced to 25 years in prison.

Their arrests came during a heightened period of cases in which the FBI and the US government arrested individuals alleged to be involved in committing "terrorist" plots within the United States.

The US government portrayed Cromitie as the ringleader of a "chilling plot", and a court complaint described him as a man seething with anti-American and antisemitic sentiment, eager to translate those feelings into bloody action.

They were arrested in Riverdale, a residential neighbourhood in the Bronx area of New York City, after allegedly planting bombs that were, in fact, packed with inert explosives supplied by the FBI.

The defendants' lawyers soon raised concerns about entrapment - a legal defence arguing that people were persuaded into committing an illegal act that they would not have committed without the involvement of law enforcement.

The defence lawyers said Hussain, the federal informant, tried to stir up the men with rhetoric and went on to choose the targets and provide the fake bombs and missiles for the defendants.

Judge McMahon lambasted the US government for sending "a villain" of an informant "to troll among the poorest and weakest of men for 'terrorists' who might prove susceptible to an offer of much-needed cash in exchange for committing a faux crime".

Kathy Manley, a lawyer representing Payen, said the ruling was "a great decision and I'm really happy that it finally happened".

Manley said that the judge's ruling may also help in other similar cases in which a confidential informant was used to convince individuals of committing violent plots on US soil.

"Maybe we can also use this decision - even though this case was unique - maybe we can use some aspects of this decision to hopefully help get other people out," said Manley.

Umar Farooq is a journalist based in Washington DC. He writes about social and political issues facing Muslim communities in the US, as well as foreign policy related to the Middle East.

FBI Targets Black People
FBI
FBI Entrapment

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Iain Carlos , Sam Carlen
DOJ Knew About - and Used - Notorious Homan Square "Black Site"
19 March 2025
It wasn't just Chicago Police operating Homan Square, the U.S.
Abayomi Azikiwe, Black Agenda Report Contributor
Malcolm X, Black Nationalism and the Cold War
19 February 2025
United States intelligence agencies kept close watch over developments in the African American struggle for freedom, justice, equality and self
NY Panther 21
Dhoruba bin-Wahad
55th Anniversary of the NY Panther 21 Case
03 April 2024
The trial of the New York Panther 21 was the moment in the Black liberation movement that ushered in an era of intensified state repression and
Uhuru
Penny Hess
Chairman Omali Yeshitela, Uhuru 3 put state on trial in fightback against bogus charges
03 April 2024
Three members of the Uhuru Movement were recently indicted on charges related to operating as "unregistered foreign agents." This attack has hu
Hands off Uhuru logo
Solyana Bekele
FBI Storms African Liberation Movement with Fabricated Charges: U.S. Government Escalates Brutal Assault
06 March 2024
The Uhuru 3 were recently indicted by the federal government, continuing a historical pattern of connecting revolutionary Black organizations a
Chairman Omali Yeshitela of the African People's Socialist Party
David S. D'Amato
The FBI’s Long History of Criminalizing Dissent
10 October 2023
Originally published in 
Not One Step Backwards! FBI Attacks the Black Liberation Movement…again. Drop the Charges NOW!
Ekenge Mayele
Not One Step Backwards! FBI Attacks the Black Liberation Movement…again. Drop the Charges NOW!
07 June 2023
The Black is Back Coalition issued this call to their 14th annual national conference to be held in St.
Durham Report Reveals the Real Threat to “Democracy” – The FBI Weaponized by Democrat Party Affiliated Elites
​​​​​​​ Ajamu Baraka, BAR editor and columnist
Durham Report Reveals the Real Threat to “Democracy” – The FBI Weaponized by Democrat Party Affiliated Elites
17 May 2023
Donald Trump calls Russiagate a "hoax" but it is in fact much worse.
First Public Comments After African People’s Socialist Party Members Indicted for Colluding with Russia
Julie Varughese
First Public Comments After African People’s Socialist Party Members Indicted for Colluding with Russia
17 May 2023
Members of the African People's Socialist Party and its Solidarity Committee were indicted on charges of acting under the influence of the Russ
U.S. Imposes Economic Sanctions on Black Community Projects
The Burning Spear
U.S. Imposes Economic Sanctions on Black Community Projects
22 March 2023
The FBI raid on the Uhuru Movement has resulted in economic sanctions like those imposed on countries that dare to be sovereign despite being u

More Stories


  • BAR Radio Logo
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Black Agenda Radio May 30, 2025
    30 May 2025
    In this week’s segment we talk about jails and prisons in New York City and State and the end of city control of the infamous Rikers Island jail. But first a Washington DC activist analyzes how the…
  • Democratic party where are you
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Afeni on Fighting the Bipartisan Fascist Consensus
    30 May 2025
    Afeni is an activist and lead organizer with Herb and Temple in Washington, DC. She joins us from Oakland to discuss politics in the U.S. and how the people can fight the fascism produced by the…
  • Rikers protest
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Eric Adams Loses Control of Rikers Island to Federal Receivership
    30 May 2025
    Our guest is Melanie Dominguez, Organizing Director, New York with the Katal Center for Equity, Health, and Justice. She joins us from New York City to discuss the federal takeover of Rikers Island…
  • Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
    Charles Rangel and the End of Black Politics
    28 May 2025
    The late Charles Rangel served as a member of the Congressional Black Caucus for more than 40 years. But the goals of Black politics and electoral politics are not necessarily the same.
  • Editors, The Black Agenda Review
    ESSAY: The Intellectual Origins of Imperialism and Zionism, Edward Said, 1977
    28 May 2025
    “In theory and in practice, then, Zionism is a degraded repetition of European imperialism.”
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us