Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

Sumo Wrestlers & Supermodels: Reimagining the Education of Black Children
David Marcus Rutherford
24 Feb 2021
Sumo Wrestlers & Supermodels: Reimagining the Education of Black Children
Educator Joel I. Plummer

 

How do we define success for Black students and the adults that they become? 

“Black children are too often robbed of the innocence provided to youth of other backgrounds.”

Sumo Wrestlers & Supermodels is the title of Joel Plummer’s most recent book. What 20 years of Teaching has Taught Me About Saving Black Children From American Schools is the subtitle.

Plummer, a legendary history teacher in Plainfield, New Jersey, presents a revolutionary reimagining of Black American schools in his 109 page book, which reads as a history lesson, a how-to manual for teachers, as well as a political demand.

He recognizes that Black students have a unique historical perspective as well as a contemporary world view that is directly at odds with the heavily propagandized image that the United States projects of itself and of its history. This unique pupil cannot be well served by a one-size-fits-all approach to education and curriculum. It would be like providing supermodel training to sumo wrestlers - or vice versa.

“Black students’ schools train them to find their place in the White power structure as it currently exists,” writes Plummer, while describing an academic world view that casts benevolent White Europeans as humanity’s main story to which everyone else is just a tangent or footnote to these central figures.  “Because schools condition Black students to see much of what White people do as normal, Black youth are rarely critical of America’s White power structure and will never seek to change it.”

Plummer passionately claims that a white supremacist education is unable to equip students to fight white supremacy. “Black Youth want to feel connected to something powerful,” argues Plummer, “yet they do not realize that their own history automatically connects them to some of the greatest and most powerful people to have ever walked the planet.”

“White supremacist education is unable to equip students to fight white supremacy.”

Black students also have the undue burden of proving their humanity and morality to teachers, argues Plummer. This includes Black teachers who often - as anyone who has attended a Black school knows - look down upon lower income students. Black children are too often robbed of the innocence provided to youth of other backgrounds. School uniforms, zero tolerance policies, and higher rates of school punishment and suspension prove to Black students that their moral inferiority is assumed.

After diagnosing the problem, Plummer brilliantly describes an ideal learning environment for Black students - one that does not come at the expense of non-Black peers. A magical place where teachers truly understand the students they teach. Where every child’s opinions and perspectives are valued, and teachers look past their flaws - both real and imagined. Where Black schools no longer resemble prisons, and the late Dr. Joe Clark is not celebrated. Where Black kids are prepared not only to excel in the world, but to shake it from its very foundation.

David Marcus Rutherford is a writer living in Plainfield, New Jersey, where he has served on the board of education.

Joel I. Plummer is an award-winning educator and photojournalist whose work has focused on amplifying people's voices that too often go unheard. He graduated from Rutgers University, where he earned a B.A. in African and African American Studies and an M.A. in history. Subsequently, he completed the Rutgers Graduate School of Education's Supervisor's Endorsement program. For more than twenty years, he has taught African American and U.S. History at the secondary level. For more than a decade, he has also taught in the Africana Studies department at Rutgers University. As a photojournalist, The Los Angeles Times, The Wall Street Journal, The Daily Beast, Newsweek, NBC, CBS, Sports Illustrated, ESPN, and numerous international media outlets have published his work. He is a product of the Plainfield Public School District in New Jersey and still lives in Plainfield with his wife, Danielle, and their children, Alexis, Morgan, and Mason. His website is located at  https://www.joelplummer.com/ .

public education

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Ezra McCoy
Roc Nation’s Lobbying Efforts Cast Suspicion on Jay Z’s Association with GOP’s Top Funder
19 June 2024
Jay Z has consistently shown his willingness to sell out his own to be used as a Black face to run cover for conservative political endeavors. 
Students of Color are Harmed Most by the “Broken Windows” Teaching
Victoria Theisen-Homer
Students of Color are Harmed Most by the “Broken Windows” Teaching
12 August 2020
“No excuses” teaching borrows from the “broken windows” theory of policing, which has been enacted in U.S. cities since the mid-1980s.
Lessons, Successes and Failures of the West Virginia Teacher Strike
Bruce A. Dixon , BAR managing editor
Lessons, Successes, Failures of the West Virginia Teachers Strike
08 March 2018
The 9 day West Virginia school strike was a long time coming, and contains a number of useful, if not new lessons.
Chicago Teachers Union and Charter School Teachers Have Joined Forces
Jeff Schuhrke
Chicago Teachers Union and Charter School Teachers Have Joined Forces
07 February 2018
“Leaders of both union locals say they don’t have a problem with charter schools per se, but rather they oppo
hustla
Bruce A. Dixon , BAR managing editor
Roland Martin: That Hustla Ova There Tryna Sell Us School Privatization
09 February 2017
Roland Martin pretends to be a journalist. But what does a guy do when the one percent won't pay for an informed public?
Dr. Walter C. Farrell Jr.
Public School Privatization Strategies: What Teachers, Unions, and Public Education Stakeholders Should Know
04 November 2015
The future of public education is not guaranteed.
drama queen
Bruce A. Dixon , BAR managing editor
Demonizing Teachers, Privatizing Schools: The Big Lies and Big Plans Behind the Atlanta School Cheating Scandal
22 April 2015
Should we be wondering if the prosecution of cheating Atlanta teachers for racketeering was racist?
Samantha Winslow
An iPad on Every Desk?: A Trojan Horse, Teachers Say
24 November 2013
School districts that place iPads and mobile devices into classrooms are being praised (and praising themselves) for "innovation.
beverly halla nd michelle rhee
Bruce A. Dixon , BAR managing editor
Why Was Atlanta's Beverly Hall Indicted For Racketeering While Michelle Rhee Won't Be?
03 April 2013
By BAR managing editor Bruce A. Dixon Atlanta's black former school superintendent and 34 other black teachers and administrators have been indicted…

More Stories


  • Caribbean Movement for Peace and Integration
    Historic Genocide Case Heard in Barbados Supreme Court: Caribbean Movement for Peace and Integration Demands Accountability Over Gaza Atrocities
    09 Jul 2025
    Barbados’ Supreme Court is now at the center of a historic genocide case against Israel, as Caribbean activists demand their government sever ties with the apartheid state.
  • Abayomi Azikiwe
    Kenyan Police Attack Youth-led Demonstrations Against Brutality
    09 Jul 2025
    At least 16 were killed in protests marking the first anniversary of mass actions against neo-liberal tax hikes and continuing state repression.
  • Said Bouamama Blog
    Settler Colonialism in Light of F. Fanon: Algeria yesterday, Kanaky today... (Part 1)
    09 Jul 2025
    As settler-colonial violence escalates from Kanaky to Palestine, Fanon’s century-old warnings are critical today—capitalism’s genocidal expansion demands revolution.
  • Inae Oh
    What $100 Billion in New ICE Funding Would Look Like
    09 Jul 2025
    The staggering increase is ICE enforcement is difficult to process. These numbers will help.
  • Margaret Kimberley and Dimitri Lascaris
    Dimitri Lascaris , Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
    Donald Trump's Big, Beautiful Con-Job w/ Margaret Kimberley
    09 Jul 2025
    This past week, the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives passed Donald Trump's signature budget bill, which Trump dubbed "One Big Beautiful Bill Act". Dimitri Lascaris spoke with Margaret…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us