Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

EDITORIAL: Haiti Had Its Sandino, Jean Lamonthe, 1929
Editors, The Black Agenda Review
27 Sep 2023
🖨️ Print Article
EDITORIAL: Haiti Had Its Sandino, Jean Lamonthe, 1929

Remembering Haitian resistance “Caco” fighter Charlemagne Peralte, demonized by the  U.S. occupation forces as a “bandit,” the same label given to Nicaraguan freedom fighter, Augusto Sandino.

In his classic 1939 study A History of Pan-African Revolt, CLR James wrote: “The docile Negro is a myth…The only place where Negroes did not revolt is in the pages of capitalist historians…. It is not strange that the Negroes revolted. It would have been strange if they had not.” We can perhaps add to James truism by saying that if Africans in revolt actually do appear in the the writings of the west, they will invariably be portrayed as “bandits,” “brigands,” “thugs,” or “gangsters:” selfish and reactionary characters whose rebellion against the malevolence of white imperial rule will be cast as as illogical and anti-patriotic.

Such was the case with the rebels who fought the US Marines during the first US occupation of Haiti (1915-1934). They were called “Cacos,” a name said to derive from a local bird of prey whose flight patterns and movements were mirrored by the rebels themselves. During the early years of the occupation, the cacos, largely groups of peasant guerillas, maintained a militant resistance to the US at a time when much of the Haitian bourgeoisie had given up on Haitian sovereignty and acquiesced to US power over the republic.

The most famous caco leader was Charlemagne Peralte. Peralte was dubbed by the US as the "supreme bandit of Haiti." He led a fierce struggle against the occupation until he was betrayed by a fellow Haitian and was ambushed and assassinated by two white US marines in Black face – Henry Hanneken and William R. Button. Both Hanneken and Button were awarded the USMC medal of honor. And the murder of Peralte is celebrated in Marine lore and mythology. Peralte, meanwhile, became a martyr and symbol of Haitian resistance, aided in part by the circulation by the Marines of a photograph of his corpse where he appears crucified.

Militant resistance to the US occupation dropped in the early 1920s. But by the fall of 1929, strikes and protests against the US spread to every part of Haiti. Peralte’s history was revived. In October, 1929, Jean Lamonthe, the secretary general of the Union Patrotique d’Haiti, wrote an editorial on Peralte that was circulated through Cyril Briggs’ Crusader News Service and published in Baltimore’s African-American owned Afro-American newspaper. The editorial was titled “Haiti had its Sandino.” Lamonthe revisits the US counterinsurgency against the Haitian peasant revolt and retells the history of Peralte. Arguing against the US racist claim that Peralte was a “bandit,” Lamothe instead compares him to the Nicaragua peasant leader and hero,  Augusto “César” Sandino – also cast as a bandit by the US.

We reprint Lamonthe’s editorial on Charlemagne Peralte below. In doing so, we hope to make two further points. First, we want to demonstrate how consistently the US and the white west have demonized Haitian resistance to imperialism, and how even the terms of Haitian disparagement remain consistent: “bandits,” “gangs,” and “thugs.” Second, we want to remind readers that in the not-so-distant past the African American press used to be more internationalist and explicitly anti-imperialist.

Haiti Had its Sandino

Jean Lamonthe

It is very highly probable that, while many people in the United States know of the heroic struggles of [Augustus] Sandino and the Nicaragua patriots, very few of the astonishing exploits of Charlemagne Prelate, the Haitian leader and patriot who, until he was surprised in his camp by a United States marine, disguised as a native, and murdered in cold blood, was one of the greatest fighters for Haitian liberty against United States Imperialism.

Charlemagne was slandered as a bandit by the marine tool of American imperialism in the Caribbean, but if Charlemagne was a bandit for resisting foreign rule so was George Washington whom Americans revere as “the father of his country,” its liberator from the oppression of British Imperialism. Charlemagne was a Caco, a Spanish word meaning “bad,” but translated “bandit” for American consumption in order to mislead the American people as to the real character of this Haitian patriot and fighter. The “Cacos” were simply black peasants who suffering from the cruelty and barbarity of the American occupation had taken the [unclear ] against the puppet Haitian government, headed by the servile tool of American capitalists interest, Louis Borno. Charlemagne joined the ranks of these patriots and soon became one of the most successful leaders against the forces of the puppet government and the United States marines who were the real power behind the throne.

THIRTY-FOUR YEARS OLD

Born at Hinch October 7, 1885, Charlemagne and won many honors and was the military governor of the district of Leogane. Returning to his native town he was immediately put in jail, shortly thereafter being sent to the chain gang in Cape Haiti. The townspeople became indignant at his treatment by the U.S. Occupation, and managed his escape.

Charlemagne then joined the revolutionaries and soon became a terror to the United States marines. He several times led groups of revolutionaries in successful attacks against the marines, once capturing a United States tank and bringing down two airplanes during a major engagement with the oppressors of Haiti. The marines then seized his aged mother as hostage, cruelly ill-treating her, but Charlemagne stifled his love for his mother and fought all the fiercer for Haitian liberation.

PAID $6000

His tactics perplexed the U.S. marines, and a prize was put on his head, “dead or alive.” To a relative, Jean Conze, the sum of six thousand dollars was promised for the betrayal of Charlemagne. This traitor consequently joined the ranks of the revolutionaries and informed the United States marines of the whereabouts of Charlemagne. A strong detachment was sent against him, but such was the terror inspired by his exploits that they dared not attack him, but resorted to strategy instead.

SLAYER PROMOTED

On the stormy night of October 31, 1919, two members of marines, Hanneken, promoted to a captaincy for his part in the outrage, and Button, blackened their faces with a number of gendarmes disguised as citizens, and led by the traitor Conze, they penetrated the outposts of the [unclear ] Terror of the Marines and entered Charlemagne’s camp. Approaching Charlemagne who was sleeping at the time, Captain Hanneken opened fire at close range, thus cowardly assassinating the Negro leader whom they had never been able to beat in battle.

Jean Lamonthe, “Haiti had its Sandino,” Afro-American, 26 October 1929.

Haiti
Cacos
Charlemagne Peralte

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


More Stories


  • Last Surviving Member of the Move 9 is Released
    Black Agenda Radio with Nellie Bailey and Glen Ford
    Last Surviving Member of the Move 9 is Released
    02 Mar 2020
    Delbert Africa, imprisoned along with eight other members of the Move organization in 1978 in the death of a Philadelphia policeman, is finally free to “tell his story,” said Mumia Abu
  • “Respectable” Black Women Fought Mass Incarceration
    Black Agenda Radio with Nellie Bailey and Glen Ford
    “Respectable” Black Women Fought Mass Incarceration
    02 Mar 2020
    Back in the days when 90 percent of southern prison inmates were Black, socially conservative Black clubwomen fought for prison reform, believing that “putting Black women in jail was hurting the B
  • If the Left Doesn’t Critique Endless War, Who Will?
    Black Agenda Radio with Nellie Bailey and Glen Ford
    If the Left Doesn’t Critique Endless War, Who Will?
    02 Mar 2020
    “We must raise the issues of war and imperialism in electoral politics in this country,” even if the Democrats don’t, said BAR senior columnist Margaret Kimberley, speaking at
  • Black America, Endless War and the Evil Genius of Russiagate
    Glen Ford , BAR executive editor
    Black America, Endless War and the Evil Genius of Russiagate
    27 Feb 2020
    The Democrats -- who are now the most aggressive war party – have succeeded in linking Donald Trump to Russia, and then lumping all critics of U.S.
  • Freedom Rider: Bernie Sanders' Foreign Policy Trap
    Margaret Kimberley, BAR senior columnist
    Freedom Rider: Bernie Sanders' Foreign Policy Trap
    26 Feb 2020
    It is time for leftists to stop giving Sanders a pass and make demands on him and all other candidates for office.
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us