Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Freedom Rider: Alabama and the Duopoly Trap
Margaret Kimberley, BAR editor and senior columnist
20 Dec 2017
🖨️ Print Article
Freedom Rider: Alabama and the Duopoly Trap
Freedom Rider: Alabama and the Duopoly Trap

“The Democrats act as though they have found the magic key to victory because they got lucky in one red state.”

The electoral process has changed very little for black people. At this late date in history our highest political expectations still amount to little more than keeping hardcore racists out of office. Any other victories are negligible. Even when we win we still lose.

All Americans live in a political world constrained by control of one far right party and one center right party. The system creates a lack of choice and yet we are constantly told that small electoral changes are fraught with great meaning.

Such was the case in Alabama where a Democrat unexpectedly prevailed in a special election for the U.S. Senate. Alabama is a lynchpin of the now 50-year old southern strategy, which switched the party of white racism from the Democrats to the Republicans. The Republicans should have won easily but instead they lost by the closest of margins.

“Moore was a caricature of the far right where one was not needed.”

Instead of choosing a bland, safe candidate they decided to nominate racist, red meat firebrand Roy Moore. Moore was a caricature of the far right where one was not needed. Not only did he speak of the era of enslavement as a time when America was great, but he was also revealed to be a serial molester of under age girls. Black Alabamans were highly motivated to get out the vote, enough whites were demotivated and Democrat Doug Jones won in a squeaker.

The lingering trauma of Donald Trump’s victory created a state of surreal ecstasy for Democrats after the Alabama election. The failing Democrats have managed to lose control of most state legislatures, both houses of Congress and the presidency but now they act as though they have found the magic key to victory because they got lucky in one red state.

Of course Jones won because of the black vote, but that is the case in elections throughout the country. Republicans deliberately gerrymander for the express purpose of creating districts free of black voters and ensuring victories for themselves.

“The great white hope for Democrats wouldn’t denounce the Republicans new tax plan.”

It was somewhat amusing to watch white liberals expressing deep gratitude to black people. The newfound respect and devotion doesn’t amount to much because they don’t understand why their party has failed so badly. But in a period of a few days Jones revealed why that is the case.

He immediately announced that he might “Vote with Republicans on some issues.” The great white hope for Democrats went further. He wouldn’t denounce the Republicans new tax plan. He would only say that he favors tax cuts for middle class people but also for corporations. This plan will create a huge give away to the richest people and begin the right wing dream of dismantling the federal government by defunding it.

Jones perfectly exemplifies the two-party trap. No one should have been shocked by his traitorous words. But most of his voters probably understood that they had a very bad choice on their hands. The black people who marshaled themselves around a Jones win live in greatest fear of rule by the segregationists. Having another two-faced Democrat in the Senate isn’t as dangerous to them as living in a world run by the Trumps and Moores of the world. Moore was an existential threat, a clear and present danger that they could not dismiss.

  1. people are right to fear rule by old school racists. When they are given any platform of legitimacy they encourage and embolden the people who would otherwise closet themselves. An open racist is a very dangerous person.

“The overseer/slave patroller image is just what Moore intended to convey to his people.”

The Jones victory will not end mass incarceration or bring living wage jobs to his state or stop police murder or do any of the things that black people need to have done. Black Alabamans are themselves aware of this conundrum that caused them to wage a fight that gained them very little.

But Jones didn’t arrive at his polling place on horseback as Moore did. That seemingly silly gesture was lost on no one. The overseer/slave patroller image is just what Moore intended to convey to his people. Black voters saw clearly, too, but reached a very different conclusion. The ancestral memory elicited by overseer Moore was just one more source of encouragement for any fence sitters on Election Day.

Donald Trump has brought the reality of black voters into stark relief. He epitomizes everything we have fought against and yet the people we look to for salvation won’t lift a finger on our behalf. Old school hatred or useless corporate Democrats. The year 2017 ends as it began with the political vicious cycle very much in place and black people are still the losers.

Margaret Kimberley’s Freedom Rider column appears weekly in BAR, and is widely reprinted elsewhere. She maintains a frequently updated blog as well at http://freedomrider.blogspot.com . Ms. Kimberley lives in New York City, and can be reached via e-Mail at Margaret.Kimberley(at)BlackAgendaReport.com

Black Electoral Politics

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Editors, The Black Agenda Review
EDITORIAL: Criticize Clinton, but Beat Bush, Manning Marable, 1992
25 September 2024
Vote for Harris, because Trump. Vote for Clinton, because Bush.
“Voting and the Black Left”: An Interview with Kamau Franklin
Kamau Franklin and Roberto Sirvent
“Voting and the Black Left”: An Interview with Kamau Franklin
12 April 2022
Kamau Franklin, founder of Community Movement Builders, speaks with BAR Boo
The Electoral College’s Racist Origins
Wilfred Codrington III
The Electoral College’s Racist Origins
20 November 2019
The nation’s oldest structural racial entitlement program is one of its most consequential: the Electoral College.
Newark’s Black-Powered Engineer: Kenneth Gibson (1932-2019)
Todd Steven Burroughs
Newark’s Black-Powered Engineer: Kenneth Gibson (1932-2019)
10 April 2019
The still-chocolate city bids farewell to its first Black mayor.

More Stories


  •  The Democrat-Republican Symbiosis
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley and Glen Ford
    The Democrat-Republican Symbiosis
    08 Jun 2021
    Like Democratic administrations before them, the Biden-Harris White House “needs the Republicans to give them cover” for failing to serve the needs of the people, said Dr.
  • Norman Finkelstein: Truth and Justice Are the Ultimate Test, Not International NGOs
    Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
    Norman Finkelstein: Truth and Justice Are the Ultimate Test, Not International NGOs
    02 Jun 2021
    Even Human Rights Watch says Israel is committing crimes against humanity in the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and in Gaza, and the idea of a Jewish state in the context of Palestine is not legit
  • Freedom Rider: Lab Leak Theory and Anti-China Mania
    Margaret Kimberley, BAR senior columnist
    Freedom Rider: Lab Leak Theory and Anti-China Mania
    02 Jun 2021
    Most virologists still believe that COVID-19 is far more likely to have originated naturally, but US espionage and disinformation agencies disagree.
  • Return of the Lab Leak Conspiracy Shows Biden is a Democrat with Trumpian Characteristics on China
    Danny Haiphong, BAR Contributing Editor
    Return of the Lab Leak Conspiracy Shows Biden is a Democrat with Trumpian Characteristics on China
    02 Jun 2021
    Now Biden and his top allies have given credence to the lab leak conspiracy, as they escalate their confrontation with China.
  • ESSAY: Knife Edge: Living with Domestic and Economic Violence, Andiaye, 2013
    Editors, The Black Agenda Review
    ESSAY: Knife Edge: Living with Domestic and Economic Violence, Andiaye, 2013
    02 Jun 2021
    Andiaye, a tireless advocate for the rights and welfare of women in Guyana, agitated against the system’s “way of organizing the economy which creates poverty and then criminalizes it.”
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us