Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

Why President Obama Won't Deliver On His Network Neutrality Promises
Bruce A. Dixon, BAR managing editor
01 Dec 2010
Why President Obama Won't Deliver On His Network Neutrality Promises
Why President Obama Won't Deliver On His Network Neutrality Promises

After two years of President Barack Obama, where are we on network neutrality, and the rights of minority communities to fight the digital redlining of our communities which lies at the core of the telecom business model? If the president didn't deliver when he had a majority in Congress, what can we expect from his White House and FCC in the next two years?

“It was a two year period in which Obama entered office with the wind at his back, with overwhelming public approval and thumping majorities in both houses of Congress.”

As a presidential candidate, Barack Obama declared he would take a back seat to nobody when it came to advocating a free and open internet. As candidate and as president, Obama uses the phrases “net neutrality” and “internet neutrality” freely and knows what they mean. He promised to appoint an FCC Chairman who shared his views.

A full two years after his election, heading into the lame duck session of Congress, we must assume the president still knows what net neutrality is, and that his FCC Chairman shares the president's views. But it looks like the president lied to us about what those views were.

For the last two years, the network neutrality ball has been in President Obama's court, and he hasn't touched it. Federal courts held during the previous administration that first cable companies, and later phone companies had the right to decide who and what could access “their” networks, and under which terms, even though these networks were invented by engineers and scientists on the government dime in the 70s and 80s, practically given away to the telecoms in 90s, and expanded with tens of billions in corporate welfare subsidies and tax breaks since. For the last two years, network neutrality advocates have waited for President Obama's FCC to officially declare it has the right and duty to regulate the internet for the public good.

It was a two year period in which Obama entered office with the wind at his back, with overwhelming public approval and thumping majorities in both houses of Congress. It was the best opportunity, if the administration ever intended such a thing, to mobilize public opinion against the greed and encroaching power of the telecom industry. It was, if we take the promises for granted as sincere an opportunity wasted.

An FCC declaration of authority over broadband internet and cable networks would be far from the end of the story. It would in fact mark a new beginning. The FCC would have to craft regulations. The president and his Congressional majority could propose laws that might extend the FCC's authority in this regard. If a majority of Congress disagreed with the president and the FCC, they too could try to pass legislation telling the FCC what it can and cannot do, and how. The president and his supporters could appeal to the public, and the courts too would have the chance to weigh in again. But most importantly, definitive presidential and FCC declarations might bring on what the telecoms and their allies fear most: an open public debate on telecommunications, cable, internet and media policies.

It's not just that the presidential candidate who needed our votes smiled at us, told us what we wanted to hear, and now intends to forget those promises. It's far worse than that. By owning the media, and managing broadcast airwaves, cable, telephone and internet networks as their private property, telecommunications companies have become the literal owners of our public and even our private conversation. Communities have no right to hear their own voices if some telecom executives can't reap a profit.

“And there is the 800 pound gorilla in the room: the pending Comcast-NBC merger...”

Broadcasters can decide, for instance, that BET, Black Evil Television, along with corporate hip-hop, gospel, TV One, syndicated infotainment talk and oldies are the totality of the African American voice. So they did. Broadcasters can follow the lead of print newspapers, who claim the internet made them do it, closing down their foreign bureaus and radically shrinking their news gathering operations to become more profitable. And they have done just that. Broadcasters can fill the empty air with entertainment news, with talking pundit heads recycling press releases from government and industry disguised as news. And that too, is the way it is.

There's also the fact that Obama's FCC Chair, Julius Genakowski is a longtime telecom lobbyist, who had a hand in writing the notorious Telecommunications Act of 1996. That law auctioned off the government-built internet to telecoms for pennies on the dollar, and lifted the ca`p on how many TV and radio stations any single owner could have in any single market, or nationally.

And there is the 800 pound gorilla in the room: the pending Comcast-NBC merger, which would place a large fraction of the internet backbone into the hands of one of the biggest producers of corporate content, a staggering vertical monopoly with endless potential for abuse. Though the merger has been pending since the opening days of the Obama administration, the president's FCC and Department of Justice are silent as sphinxes on the matter, while Comcast is raining money on members of Congress, and black and Latino advocacy groups such as LULAC, the Urban League and the NAACP. Can this notoriously corporate-friendly president ever bring himself to say no to Comcast-NBC?

It doesn't take rocket science to predict what the craven and corporate-friendly Obama administration wants to do. The president is already doing what he intends to do. His telecom lobbyist-in-chief at the FCC isn't opposing the Comcast-NBC merger because the president doesn't intend to. There's no assertion of FCC authority over the internet because President Obama won't choose the public interest over corporate interests here either, any more than he has done anyplace else. The president can stall another month, and a new Congress will be in town. Then he can crow a little, but not too loudly or forcefully, about being for internet neutrality again, but how tea party Republicans in the Congress are holding it up. That's what the president has done, and what we can reasonably expect he'll do.

The question now is what will what was once thought of as the movement for media justice do. Will it hold its breath another year, waiting to be noticed by the president? Will it forget its own problems and come together to re-elect Barack Obama for a second term? After all, Mitt Romney and Sarah Palin are worse, right?

Bruce Dixon is managing editor at Black Agenda Report and a state committee member of the Green Party in Georgia. He's based in Marietta GA and can be reached at bruce.dixon(at)blackagendareort,.com.

net neutrality
Democrats

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Joe Biden Wants Us to Forget His Past. We Won't
Adolph Reed , Cornel West
Joe Biden Wants Us to Forget His Past. We Won't
08 May 2019
Joe Biden is the purest example of the corporate Democrats that turned the party decisively towards war, austerity and race-baiting in a previous e
The People v. The Information Monopolies: Case Continued
Ann Garrison , BAR contributor
The People v. The Information Monopolies: Case Continued
19 December 2018
Democrats failed to get enough votes to repeal the FCC’s undoing of net neutrality, but there’s still time to change some member’s votes.
Democratic Party Politics 101 with Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the Corporate Media
Danny Haiphong , BAR contributor
Democratic Party Politics 101 with Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the Corporate Media
25 July 2018
“Democrats have firmly implanted themselves on the side of Wall Street and its militarist corporate partners.”
Bernie Sanders: “Don’t Be Rude to White Nationalists, Do What Alexandria Did”
Paul Street
Bernie Sanders: “Don’t Be Rude to White Nationalists, Do What Alexandria Did”
11 July 2018
“People Have a Right to Go Into a Restaurant and Have Dinner”
Freedom Rider: Ocasio-Cortez and the Left
Margaret Kimberley , BAR editor and senior columnist
Freedom Rider: Ocasio-Cortez and the Left
04 July 2018
“Ocasio-Cortez deserves credit for beating a corrupt but powerful system.”
Why the Green Party Hasn't Taken Off
Bruce A. Dixon , BAR managing editor
Why Our Green Parties Haven't Taken Off
30 May 2018
A solid majority of Americans polled want to see a third party compete with Republicans and Democrats.
Barber Sermon on Militarism Reveals Philosophical & Political Limitations of the Poor Peoples Campaign
Bruce A. Dixon , BAR managing editor
Barber Sermon on Militarism Reveals Philosophical & Political Limitations of the Poor Peoples Campaign
11 May 2018
"Rev.
Danny Haiphong , BAR contributor
The Democratic “Deep State” Takeover and the Moribund State of American Politics
11 April 2018
“Democrats make gun violence in America the primary midterm election issue because the passage of single payer healthcare, a scale back
bernie on russiagate
Ann Garrison , BAR contributor
The Reckless Resistance
21 February 2018
“Americans didn’t need Russia’s social media meme bombers to find writers, broadcasters, and social media aficionados saying horrible t
Danny Haiphong , BAR contributor
Donkey In A Hole: Don't Expect Democrats To Change Much in 2018
10 January 2018
The 2018 midterm elections are fast approaching.

More Stories


  • Black Agenda Radio January 27, 2023
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Black Agenda Radio January 27, 2023
    27 Jan 2023
    Police killings increase, Nicaragua, and Cuba in Africa
  • Record Number of Police Killings in 2022
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Record Number of Police Killings in 2022
    27 Jan 2023
    Samuel Sinyangwe is founder of the Mapping Police Violence Project.
  • Observations of Nicaragua's Revolutionary Process
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Observations of Nicaragua's Revolutionary Process
    27 Jan 2023
    Erica Caines is publisher of the website Hood Communist. She is also co-coordinator of the Black Alliance for Peace Haiti/Americas team.
  • Cuba, Africa, and Apartheid’s End: Africa’s Children Return - Part 1
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Cuba, Africa, and Apartheid’s End: Africa’s Children Return - Part 1
    27 Jan 2023
    Isaac Saney is a Cuba and Black studies specialist and historian at Dalhousie University in Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada. He is the author of the recently published book Cuba, Africa, and Apartheid’s…
  • The State Repression of U.S. Settler Colonialism in The South: BAP ATLANTA STATEMENT
    Black Alliance for Peace Atlanta City-Wide Alliance
    The State Repression of U.S. Settler Colonialism in The South: BAP ATLANTA STATEMENT
    25 Jan 2023
    The plan for an Atlanta police training facility known as "Cop City" is the latest phase of state repression in that region. 
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us