Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Cartoon
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Book Review: Learning From the Soviet Collapse to Ignite a Socialist Revival
Danny Haiphong, BAR contributor
20 Nov 2019
Book Review: Learning From the Soviet Collapse to Ignite a Socialist Revival
Book Review: Learning From the Soviet Collapse to Ignite a Socialist Revival

The rise of liberal capitalist tendencies in the Communist Party led to Perestroika and the eventual overthrow of Soviet socialism.

“The legacy of the Soviet Union been shaped by lies and anti-communist smears.”

Author and socialist Carlos Martinez has written an invaluable book for the struggle for socialism in the 21st century. The End of the Beginning: Lessons of the Soviet Collapse acknowledges what too few in the socialist movement today are willing to confront: that an understanding of socialism is impossible without a critical look into the rise and fall of the Soviet Union. There are many reasons for the virtual erasure of the Soviet Union from the consciousness of activists within socialist circles in the U.S. and West. The Soviet Union represented the first experiment with socialism in a thoroughly capitalist world. Just as Haiti has been punished non-stop by the imperial powers for being the first nation to overthrow the yoke of slavery and colonialism, so too has the legacy of the Soviet Union been shaped by lies and anti-communist smears.

The U.S. and its imperial allies attempted to wipe the world clean of socialism after the Soviet Union disintegrated in 1991. U.S.-led global capitalism, we were told, was here to stay indefinitely. However, the permanency of capitalism turned out to be a fraudulent claim rather than a credible theory. China has lifted eight-hundred million people out of poverty and become the second largest economy in the world by implementing “socialism with Chinese characteristics.” In Latin America, socialism has made a resurgence in the political life of the working class. Despite the brutal and relentless efforts of entrenched, U.S.-backed neocolonial elites, massive social movements in Nicaragua, Venezuela, Argentina and a host of Latin American countries have successfully elected socialist-oriented political parties into state power. 

“In Latin America, socialism has made a resurgence in the political life of the working class.”

Even still, the legacy of the Soviet Union rarely comes up in the socialist political dialogue of the 21st century. Martinez breaks the silence on the Soviet Union by laying out a roadmap for those seeking to understand why the first workers state collapsed and what we can learn from it. He begins by acknowledging the vast achievements of the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union, Martinez says, “succeeded in creating a completely different type of society: one that deeply valued equality, shared prosperity, social justice, solidarity, culture, and education.” In seventy-four short years, Russia was transformed from one of the poorest countries on the planet to an industrial powerhouse where workers called the shots. Some of the achievements of the Soviet Union highlighted include full employment, universal healthcare, the elevation of the condition of women, and the extensive material commitment of the Soviet system to the liberation of oppressed nations from colonial domination. 

The Soviet Union’s achievements revolutionized life for workers in the Soviet Union. Martinez helps readers understand why worker control of the state and a subsequent rise in living standards could not prevent the fall of the Soviet Union. To understand the development of any phenomenon, social or otherwise, one must weigh its internal and external contradictions. This is the essence of dialectical materialism. Martinez’s book follows the tenants of dialectical materialism by weighing the internal and external contradictions of Soviet development.

“In seventy-four short years, Russia was transformed from one of the poorest countries on the planet to an industrial powerhouse.”

The Soviet Union faced harsh external pressures throughout its existence. Socialist industrialization in the Soviet Union occurred under conditions of war directly following the Russian revolution of 1917. The Soviet Union was first tasked with rebuilding the country from devastation following the First World War, which was then depleted by a civil war backed by the imperialist powers. It is often forgotten that the Soviet Union was also the principle target of Nazi invasion during the Second World War. Despite the death of millions of Soviets and the massive destruction of infrastructure produced by decades of war, the Soviet economy was an unquestionable success in its early years, producing scientific achievements and growth rates that rivaled and even surpassed the West. Socialist reconstruction focused primarily on improving the condition workers and developing an industrial base capable of eradicating the miserable conditions left by the scourge of imperialist war. 

The Soviet Union was rebuilt at a breakneck pace because, unlike the anarchy of the capitalist market, the Soviet Union employed a central plan that directed economic development toward the needs of society rather than profit. However, a more complex economy made central planning increasingly difficult over time. Labor productivity diminished due to overemployment and consumer goods were scarce. An underground economy emerged that helped laid the basis for private economic development. Furthermore, the Soviet Union provided a great deal of aid to national liberation movements abroad but was surrounded by a predominantly capitalist and hostile European world. Economic stagnation would eventually ensue as the Soviet economy struggled to meet the rising expectations of the masses.

“The Soviet economy was an unquestionable success in its early years.”

Perhaps the most compelling aspect of The End of the Beginning is its focus on the subjective mistakes of Soviet leadership. Martinez engages with the errors of Soviet leadership in the post-Stalin period, particularly in relation to the failure to defend the integrity of the Communist Party. The infamous “secret speech” given by Nikita Khrushchev jumpstarted a decay in popular confidence in the Communist Party of the Soviet Union and opened the door to ideological stagnation. Ideological stagnation allowed academics, party bureaucrats, and economic managers to grow increasingly influential over party affairs. Martinez argues quite convincingly that the internal attack on Soviet ideology rendered the workers state vulnerable to capitalist restoration.

According to Martinez, “the issue of maintaining a workers’ state and preventing the political domination of pro-capitalist ‘liberals’ is arguably the most important lesson to be learned from the collapse of the USSR.” The rise of liberal capitalist tendencies in the CPSU led to Perestroika and the eventual overthrow of Soviet socialism. China has avoided a similar fate by maintaining the integrity of the communist party. The Communist Party of China maintains its leadership role over economic development. This has kept capitalist elements within society from consuming the workers’ state and has allowed the Communist Party of China to use market reforms to modernize the standard of living of the masses without relinquishing the central plan.  

“Ideological stagnation allowed academics, party bureaucrats, and economic managers to grow increasingly influential over party affairs.”

All of this and more is explained in The End of the Beginning. Socialists all over the world, but especially in the United States and the West, should read this book if they are interested in countering anti-Soviet dogma while maintaining a sober analysis of what led to the Soviet Union’s demise. The U.S. and Western world are without a communist party capable of transforming society the way that the Communist Party of the Soviet Union revolutionized material conditions in the east. Since 1991, workers in Russia, Eastern Europe, the U.S., and much of Western world have seen their standard of living decline dramatically. It is obvious that the formation of a vanguard party will be a necessary ingredient to reversing the many miseries that late stage capitalism has imposed upon the working class. The successes and failures of the Soviet Union help us understand why and Martinez’s latest book is not afraid to approach them from a revolutionary perspective.

Danny Haiphong is an activist and journalist in the New York City area. He and Roberto Sirvent are co-authors of the book entitled American Exceptionalism and American Innocence: A People’s History of Fake News--From the Revolutionary War to the War on Terror (Skyhorse Publishing). He can be reached at [email protected], on Twitter @spiritofho, and on Youtube at The Left Lens with Danny Haiphong

COMMENTS?

Please join the conversation on Black Agenda Report's Facebook page at http://facebook.com/blackagendareport

Or, you can comment by emailing us at [email protected]

socialism

Trending

Elizabeth Warren Wants Green Bombs, not a Green New Deal
Parallels Between Black and Palestinian Struggles
Cory Booker Hates Public Schools
Bill Cosby Should Have Been Denounced by Black America Long Ago
The Black Wall Around Barack Obama: Who Does It Protect Him Against?
How Complacency, Complicity of Black Misleadership Class Led to Supreme Court Evisceration of the Voting Rights Act

Related Stories

Socialists of Color to the Front
Eli Day
Socialists of Color to the Front
21 August 2019
LeftRoots’ stated purpose: to strategize around “21st-century socialism” and then bring people together to help get there.
Can the “Wretched” Rule? On Socialism, the State, and the Future of Humanity
Danny Haiphong , BAR contributor
Can the “Wretched” Rule? On Socialism, the State, and the Future of Humanity
23 January 2019
it is merely a fantasy to believe that the struggle to bring socialism in the United States will not involve a revolutionary struggle against the s
Another Look At Martin Luther King Jr.
Norman Richmond aka Jalali
Another Look At Martin Luther King Jr.
16 January 2019
Dr King was a radical, a democratic socialist who saw economic transformation and social justice as inseparable.
Ocasio-Cortez, Socialism, War and Austerity
Glen Ford , BAR executive editor
Ocasio-Cortez, Socialism, War and Austerity
10 January 2019
It’s good that there are now plenty of young people that like the idea of socialism.
On Rage, Reading Books, and Other Necessities for the “Millennial Generation”
Danny Haiphong , BAR contributor
On Rage, Reading Books, and Other Necessities for the “Millennial Generation”
07 November 2018
Young people in the US are increasingly open to socialism and radical ideas, but less likely to study the science of revolutionary change.
Theory 101: Class Struggle in the Age of US Imperial Decline
Danny Haiphong , BAR contributor
Theory 101: Class Struggle in the Age of US Imperial Decline
03 October 2018
The focus on separate “identities” has led to numerous academic theories and non-profit career opportunities but no real power for oppressed and wo
Ocasio-Cortez’s Tweet to McCain means she IS a Democrat and ISN’T a Socialist
Danny Haiphong , BAR contributor
Ocasio-Cortez’s Tweet to McCain means she IS a Democrat and ISN’T a Socialist
12 September 2018
It should be all too clear by now that the “Resistance” to Donald Trump within the US power structure is just a public relations stunt to sow popul
An Open Letter to ‘Socialists’ Who Might be Fronting for the Democratic Party
Quetzal Cáceres
An Open Letter to ‘Socialists’ Who Might be Fronting for the Democratic Party
22 August 2018
Any socialist who thought, as I did, that Ocasio-Cortez would be our socialist champion should watch the entire 27-minute PBS Firing Li
An Interview With Boots Riley: “In the World of Film, We’ve Edited out All Rebellion”
Chip Gibbons and Boots Riley
An Interview With Boots Riley: “In the World of Film, We’ve Edited out All Rebellion”
08 August 2018
“I think the movement needs to organize the 93 percent of the work force that is not organized.”
What Would An Authentic 21st Century US Left Look Like?
Bruce A. Dixon , BAR managing editor
What Would An Authentic 21st Century US Left Look Like?
07 June 2018
Let’s face it, the US left is a long way right now from contending for power.

More Stories


  • “Booming” Economy Means More Bad Jobs and Faster Race to the Bottom
    Glen Ford , BAR executive editor
    “Booming” Economy Means More Bad Jobs and Faster Race to the Bottom
    05 Dec 2019
    For the past 30 years, no matter which party has been in power, the US economy has produced more and more “bad” jobs – because the Race to the Bottom is ruling class policy.
  • Freedom Rider: Liberals Love the Military
    Margaret Kimberley , BAR editor and senior columnist
    Freedom Rider: Liberals Love the Military
    04 Dec 2019
    Self-styled liberals believe they are a better class of people than Trump, but are bigger supporters of unjust wars than the so-called “deplorables.”
  • Colin Kaepernick Shows that American Innocence is a White Supremacist Sport
    BAR Contributing Editor Danny Haiphong
    Colin Kaepernick Shows that American Innocence is a White Supremacist Sport
    04 Dec 2019
    The Black struggle for dignity and self-determination will forever be criminalized as a problem by the white elite and their hirelings in the Black misleadership class.
  • Millions Die in Congo While the UN Keeps the Peace
    Contributing Editor Ann Garrison
    Millions Die in Congo While the UN Keeps the Peace
    04 Dec 2019
    The UN Peacekeeping Mission has been in Congo for 20 years without protecting the people or the peace.
  • Boss Tweet’s Blitzkrieg 
    BAR Poet-in-Residence Raymond Nat Turner
    Boss Tweet’s Blitzkrieg 
    04 Dec 2019
    I wake in a cold sweat, scrambling for the internet— What salvoes were let loose while we slept?  How badly Bombed is the safety net? What rights are left?
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us