Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

The Silencing of Fred Dube
Abena Ampofoa Asare
24 Jan 2024
🖨️ Print Article
Fred Dube at a 1981 UN meeting, “South African Women and Labour under Apartheid.”
Fred Dube at a 1981 UN meeting, “South African Women and Labour under Apartheid.” Image: UN Photo

Forty years ago, the exiled South African activist dared to teach Zionism critically and he was subjected to a ferocious attack. The treatment he was subjected to is being repeated today.

Originally published in Boston Review.

At the State University of New York at Stony Brook, the syllabus for an Africana Studies summer course entitled The Politics of Race includes prompts for students in need of term paper guidance. The twelve optional topics are deliberately provocative: “Can a Christian or a democrat be a racist?” “I.Q. tests are a means for blaming the victim.” “Zionism is as much racism as Nazism was racism.” A historian visiting from Israel’s Ben-Gurion University complains that the latter topic, thus the course, thus the professor are examples of anti-Semitism. An uproar ensues.

This year is 1983. The professor under scrutiny is Ernest Frederick Dube, the South African anti-apartheid activist, Robben Island survivor, Cornell-trained psychologist, husband, and father. Branded as an anti-Semite, he will be gone from the Stony Brook campus by 1987.

When I began teaching at Stony Brook, my colleagues in Africana Studies told me Dube’s story in different ways. Each time, I understood the lesson: the politics of Israel-Palestine are cordoned-off; they are an arena where you dare not tread. Even when, like Dube, your faculty peers support you, students lead protests against your dismissal, and you are a hero of the South African anti-apartheid movement, you may still end up losing your home and position.

Read the entire essay here.

 

Abena Asare is Associate Professor of Modern African Affairs at Stony Brook University. She is author of Truth Without Reconciliation: A Human Rights History of Ghana and When Will the Joy Come: Black Women in the Ivory Tower.

South Africa
Israel
Zionism
Academia

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Michael F. Brown
Trump Ambassador Pick Vows to Pressure South Africa Over Gaza Genocide Case
05 November 2025
The nomination of an ambassador to South Africa who vows to "pressure" the country over its Gaza case confirms that the U.S.
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
A Tale of Two Ceasefires: Gaza and DRC
22 October 2025
The US has negotiated ceasefires in Gaza and the DRC’s eastern Kivu Provinces, but the killing, displacement, and devastation in both continue.
Editors, The Black Agenda Review
ESSAY: David and Goliath Collaborate in Africa, Africa Research Group, 1969
15 October 2025
“Israel has played a relatively invisible but strategically important role in Africa as a servant of the United States…”
Raïs Neza Boneza
Through an African Lens: The Israel-Iran Conflict and a Call for Peace
16 July 2025
Western cameras frame this as Israel vs.
Jon Jeter
Fleeing Imaginary Persecution at Home, South African ‘Refugees’ May Find the Grass is Not Greener in America
14 May 2025
The Trump administration’s decision to fast-track asylum for white South Africans—claiming "persecution"—is a political stunt, ignoring that th
Editors, The Black Agenda Review
ESSAY: White Racism and Black Consciousness, Stephen Bantu Biko, 1971
12 February 2025
Steve Biko long ago diagnosed the pathological cruelty and rot of white society.
Jon Jeter
Landless and Poor, Black South Africans Say they will Defy Trump and Move Ahead, Finally, with Land Reform
12 February 2025
A torrent of false and racist claims culminated in a presidential executive order suspending any aid to South Africa.
Abayomi Azikiwe, Black Agenda Report Contributor
Namibia Blocks Vessel Carrying Explosives to Israel
04 September 2024
The ruling SWAPO party says it is upholding international law.
x
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
The Victims’ Pact: Rwanda and Israel
31 July 2024
Rwanda weaponizes the Rwandan Genocide to justify its violence in the Democratic Repu
Irvin Jim, NUMSA General Secretary
NUMSA Statement on the National Elections Results and Coalitions
19 June 2024
With its recent historic loss of the Parliament majority, the African National Congress has formed a coalition with the Democratic Alliance, he

More Stories


  • Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
    Use and Abuse of the Genocide Convention
    05 Nov 2025
    Genocide crime, as defined by the UN Convention on Genocide, is sadly common. When does the world decide to respond? 
  • Mosaab Baba
    Sudan: Africa's Regional Neo-Colonial War
    05 Nov 2025
    The conflict in Sudan is a neo-colonial takeover, with United States ally the UAE using a proxy force to exploit that nation for its resources and strategic position.
  • Tunde Osazua
    Nigeria in the Crosshairs: Separating Fact from Fiction in the Looming Crisis
    05 Nov 2025
    The threat of U.S. military action in Nigeria has little to do with protecting Christians and everything to do with domestic U.S. politics and international political games. The "genocide" claim…
  • Anthony Karefa Rogers-Wright
    Basis for Climate and Environmental Liberation
    05 Nov 2025
    A movement born from radical action now risks being defanged by racism and elite capture. As the climate crisis continues to grow, the only viable path is a radical struggle for climate and…
  • Kwabena Dennot Nyack
    Grenada – Forward Ever: The Caribbean as a Zone of Peace
    05 Nov 2025
    Grenada's revolution was a brief and brilliant moment that was undone by errors and U.S. intervention. Its legacy must be remembered as the U.S. continues to violate the sovereignty of nations in the…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us