Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Weaponized Words: Are the Black Misleadership Class Race Traitors or Just Following Their Own Class Interests?
Bruce A. Dixon, BAR managing editor
11 Jan 2018
🖨️ Print Article

My comrade and colleague Glen Ford observed last month that our words here at Black Agenda Report are or ought to be weapons. He's right. If we’re on the case, Black Agenda Report is about the business of popularizing correct and careful analyses, accurate enough to educate and inform the uninformed, and subject to revision as new facts come into view.

That’s why I wrote back in December that I wouldn't be using the term "black misleadership class" any more. Back when we started using it, I understood the term as defining the politics of a particular cohort of black political leaders, elected and appointed officials, black business and religious leaders, the heads of nonprofit organizations and aspirants to these spots all of whom owe their careers to the pretense that they somehow "represent" the total black community. Of course they didn't, and if that was ever their objective, they failed.

Why? Why did this black misleadership class fail to "represent" us? Was it because of their faulty racial politics, or their faulty class politics? Was it because our black misleadership class was never truly "black enough" or were they just following their own class interest as opposed to the class interests of the vast majority of those they purportedly represent? This is not nitpicking, it's a vitally important question, because the two possible answers lead us in two radically different directions.

If we say that the so-called black misleadership class failed us by "letting the race down" then we are very clearly implying that there exists somewhere, somehow, a kind of good racial uplift politics which the black misleadership class might have engaged in but did not. This notion of the failure of the black misleadership class means we solve the problem by seeking or developing not more black misleaders, but "real" black leaders whose job it will be to help discover, define and enact the kind of racial uplift politics the black misleaders did not or could not. But who decides what a "real" black leader is, and on what basis? If we suppose that the cause of the black misleadership class's failure to represent us is their bad racial politics, what's the remedy? For them to get blacker? What does that even look like? It's it's a supposition that leads us nowhere.

On the other hand, if we suppose that the black misleadership class failed to legitimately "represent" black people because the class interests of this leadership cohort conflicted or did not coincide with the those of the working classes to which the vast majority of black people actually belong, lots of doors open up for us.

Only if we understand the disastrous record of the black misleadership class as following its own class interests, rather than as "race traitors" can we understand why black leaders have embraced gentrification, the dismantling of public education, austerity, war and empire as facts of life.

I'm pretty certain that Glen and Margaret and Ajamu and Danny and our poet and many of you agree that the failure of the black misleadership class is not a failure of their blackness, but of their class politics. Unlike Glen at this point, I want my own language to accurately reflect the class origin of this failure, and not lend itself to the false interpretation that that the black misleadership class failed us because they were MIS-leaders instead of true leaders or captured by the forces of anti-blackness, or any of that. I am not saying, and I never said that Glen and the rest of the BAR crew believe any of that crap. But as Glen says our words are weapons. We are in the business of crafting and popularizing precise language which can serve as a guide to correct action.

So we have to be alert to the possibility that our language can be misinterpreted or quoted out of context. That’s why I am not using the term black misleadership class much any more. Our words are indeed weapons, and I want mine aimed at the right place.

For Black Agenda Radio, I’m Bruce Dixon. Find us on the web at www.blackagendareport.com and on SoundCloud at Black Agenda Radio and Black Agenda Radio commentaries.



 

Black Misleadership Class

Related Podcasts

Black Agenda Radio
Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
Black Agenda Radio June 28, 2024
28 June 2024
In this week’s segment, we discuss the Shelby County v.
Buffalo police department traffic stop
Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
Buffalo's Black Mayor Targets Communities of Color to Raise Revenue
07 June 2024
In a lawsuit against the City of Buffalo challenging unconstitutional and racially discriminatory traffic enforcement practices by the Buffalo Poli
Black Agenda Radio
Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
Black Agenda Radio March 22, 2024
22 March 2024
This week we hear about right wing forces in San Francisco who worked with the Black democratic mayor to criminalize poverty in a classic case of B

More Stories


  • Reagan’s “Shining City on a Hill” Was Really a Mirage
    Dr.Wilmer J. Leon, III
    Reagan’s “Shining City on a Hill” Was Really a Mirage
    26 Jan 2022
    It is best to be wary when American politicians create expressions like "shining city on a hill." One of Reagan's signature phrases has been reused time and again by republicans and democrats a
  • Automating Banishment: The Surveillance and Policing of Looted Land, a New Report from the Stop LAPD Spying Coalition
    Stop LAPD Spying Coalition
    Automating Banishment: The Surveillance and Policing of Looted Land, a New Report from the Stop LAPD Spying Coalition
    26 Jan 2022
    Surveillance is an integral part of policing in this country.
  • Seven Myths about the January 6th Capitol Building Incident
    Roger D. Harris
    Seven Myths about the January 6th Capitol Building Incident
    26 Jan 2022
    The events of January 6, 2021 at the Capitol have been discussed and written about endlessly, but without much useful analysis.
  • Democrats and Trading People for Political Power
    Daniel Melo
    Democrats and Trading People for Political Power
    26 Jan 2022
    Electoral politics in this country is a cover for oligarchic rule. Democratic party victories provide very little material benefit for the people they depend upon for support.  
  • Legacy of a Black Revolutionary:  Black Agenda Report (BAR)
    Mary Uyematsu Kao
    Legacy of a Black Revolutionary: Black Agenda Report (BAR)
    26 Jan 2022
    Glen Ford's legacy is recognized all over the nation. Japanese- American newspaper Rafu Shimpo printed this tribute to his work. 
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us