Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Freedom Rider: Black Misleaders Act Like Republicans
Margaret Kimberley, BAR editor and senior columnist
05 Apr 2017
🖨️ Print Article

by BAR editor and senior columnist Margaret Kimberley

Black politics in Baltimore has sunk to the very bottom of the sewer, with mayor Catherine Pugh’s veto of a rise in the minimum wage. “Black people have no reason to rejoice with the Pughs of the world in office, because they are just as eager to act against their interests if powerful people give them marching orders.” Push is “a typical member of the black misleadership class, who live off of the crumbs of corporate tribute.”

Freedom Rider: Black Misleaders Act Like Republicans

by BAR editor and senior columnist Margaret Kimberley

“She must be shunned as the traitor that she is.”

What good are Democrats if they act just like Republicans? What good are black elected officials if they harm black people? These questions are not mere thought experiments for the people of Baltimore, Maryland. It is a reality they must face after their Democratic mayor consigned the working poor in that city to a bleak economic future.

The Baltimore city council passed a bill that would have raised the minimum wage from $8.75 to $15.00 over a five-year period. The cry for a $15.00 per hour minimum wage has rallied activists across the country, despite the fact that this arbitrary figure is far from a living wage in most of the country. Even where the $15.00 minimum has become a reality it is often phased in over a period of years, making this already over hyped figure worth very little.

The legislation would nevertheless have had an immediate positive impact on Baltimore workers had the mayor not vetoed the legislation. Mayor Catherine Pugh is a Democrat, and a black woman. Those facts should have some political meaning, but the death of both black politics and of the Democratic party are epitomized in Pugh’s treachery. Pugh broke a promise that she made during her 2016 campaign, a promise which gave her financial and voter mobilization support from unions.

“The death of both black politics and of the Democratic party are epitomized in Pugh’s treachery.”

Pugh’s explanation for her decision came straight from the Republican Party playbook. She said she was concerned that an increased minimum wage would increase unemployment, which is what Republicans have falsely claimed for decades. Pugh is not alone among Democrats in talking out of both sides of her mouth. While the party makes a claim to represent working people they have passed on every opportunity to prove it.

In 2009 and 2010 Barack Obama was president and Democrats controlled the House and the Senate. They were in a position to make the federal minimum wage any figure they chose. But in 2009 they increased it a mere 70 cents per hour. Republican control would have meant no increase at all, but that is no reason to praise the Democrats for refusing to meet what was once among the low hanging fruit of their policy decisions.

Corporate America has no reason to fear Democratic politicians because they are as much their errand boys and girls as Republicans are. Black people have no reason to rejoice with the Pughs of the world in office, because they are just as eager to act against their interests if powerful people give them marching orders.

“The Democratic Party and their black misleaders must be abandoned altogether and the duopoly must be torn up root and branch.”

There is nothing mysterious about who spoke to Pugh in support of the veto. Maryland business groups praised her decision and that is a reason to express dismay and to ask hard questions. This majority black city is one of the poorest in the country and thousands of workers there struggle to survive on an income that guarantees poverty.

Those workers and every black Baltimorean have a duty to turn their backs on Pugh and to denounce her at every opportunity. She must be shunned as the traitor that she is. Invitations should be withdrawn, pulpits should no longer welcome her presence. She is an enemy and she must be treated like one. But apparently she isn’t alone.

City Council members who supported the legislation could have voted to override it but chose not to do so. The details of the political trickery may be murky but the end result is obvious and the working poor will be left in the lurch.

This disaster is an opportunity not only for the people of Baltimore but the entire country to question their political alliances. Pugh is a typical member of the black misleadership class, those politicians and supposed leaders who live off of the crumbs of corporate tribute and misplaced loyalty from their constituents.

“Pugh broke a promise that she made during her 2016 campaign, a promise which gave her financial and voter mobilization support from unions.”

The change that is required in this country cannot consist of incremental reform. What do workers in Baltimore and other cities do with double crossing politicos like Pugh? They can endorse someone else and face the same fate. Or they can recognize that engaging with the duopoly and the black misleaders is always a suckers bet. The Democratic Party and their black misleaders must be abandoned altogether and the duopoly must be torn up root and branch.

Every defeat like the minimum wage veto ought to be an advertisement for self determinationist politics and a reason for black people to lose their fear of helping the Republicans. Democrats are also the white peoples party if workers are treated like fools who should happily race to the bottom.

Pugh should be the poster child for dumping the Democrats for good. They lie to their voters, parrot Republican talking points and act on them too. What good are they? They aren’t any good at all and it is time to say so clearly and unequivocally.

We have nothing to lose except our political chains.

Margaret Kimberley's Freedom Rider column appears weekly in BAR, and is widely reprinted elsewhere. She maintains a frequently updated blog as well as at http://freedomrider.blogspot.com. Ms. Kimberley lives in New York City, and can be reached via e-Mail at Margaret.Kimberley(at)BlackAgendaReport.com.

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


More Stories


  • Palestinian Alternative Revolutionary Path Movement
    Georges Ibrahim Abdallah: “Together, and only together, do we win.”
    04 Feb 2026
    After 41 years in French captivity, revolutionary militant Georges Ibrahim Abdallah speaks, offering an analysis of October 7th, global fascism, and the Palestinian resistance.
  • Prince Kapone
    Reuters’ ‘Market Story’ and the American Pole: PetroChina, Venezuelan Oil, and the Siege That Calls Itself Trade
    04 Feb 2026
    Reuters sells custodial plunder as a pricing issue, turning blockade into “market caution.” We restore the missing record: seizures, supervision, and the re-routing of Venezuelan oil revenue through…
  • Mafa Kwanisai Mafa
    Trump, White Farmers and the War on Zimbabwe’s Sovereignty: Why Africans Must Reject this Neo-Colonial Push
    04 Feb 2026
    The push by white farmers to enlist Donald Trump in a compensation battle over Zimbabwean land is a brazen, neo-colonial plot to undo African liberation history.
  • Communist Party Marxist - Kenya , Booker Omole
    Statement of Solidarity with the Islamic Republic of Iran Down with US Imperialism Forward with the Sovereignty and Dignity of Oppressed Nations
    04 Feb 2026
    The imperial assault on Iran is punishment for the crime of sovereignty, a protracted siege that oppressed nations worldwide recognize as a weapon threatening their own future.
  • BAR Radio Logo
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley
    Black Agenda Radio January 30, 2026
    30 Jan 2026
    In this week’s segment, we talk about human rights and citizenship and the Trump administration's persecution of Haitian immigrants. We begin with a discussion of the need to protect the 14th…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us