Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Debate Moderator Lester Holt Asks Zero Questions About Poverty, Abortion, Climate Change
Adam Johnson
28 Sep 2016
🖨️ Print Article

by Adam Johnson

This Monday showed there were multiple ways to fix a crooked presidential debate.  The first way is to exclude everyone but the representatives of the two capitalist parties.  A second way explored elsewhere in this issue was outside crowd control, and a third, as FAIR's Adam Johnson explained, was to let the crooks decide what questions they'd be asked.

Lester Holt Asks Zero Questions About Poverty, Abortion, Climate Change

by Adam Johnson

Originally published by our friends at FAIR.ORG

Presidential debates do as much to illustrate corporate media priorities as they do to showcase the candidates. They provide a snapshot into what the media, in this case represented by NBC’s Lester Holt, prioritizes as issues worthy of discussion.

A week before the debate,Comcast-owned NBC announced the topics, and one could already tell we weren’t going to be in for a substantive evening: “Achieving prosperity,” “America’s direction” and “securing America.” This generic approach lead to a generic debate that focused mostly on horserace disputes and vague, open-ended questions about taxes and jobs.

Holt didn’t ask any questions about the following topics: poverty, abortion, climate change,  immigration, healthcare, student debt, privacy, LGBTQ rights or drug policy. (NBC reported before the debate that abortion and immigration were two of the policy issues that voters were most interested in, as indicated byGoogle searches, along with the economy and police shootings.)

What was discussed: jobs, Trump’s tax returns, who did or didn’t support the Iraq War, raising taxes on the rich, race (framed mostly in a way that pandered to Trump’s theme of a country in disarray), Russian cyberattacks, ISIS, Obama’s birth certificate, Clinton’s physical appearance and whether the candidates would accept the election results.

Obviously, a moderator can’t cover every topic in a 90-minute debate, but one can hardly imagine a scenario where the candidates weren’t asked to discuss taxes on the wealthy, ISIS and the specter of Russian cyberattacks—topics, not coincidentally, the average person is rarely if ever affected by, but receive nonstop discussion on cable news and opinion sections. Holt even framed raising taxes on the wealthy—whose share of national income has multiplied sixffold over the last 40 years—as something Clinton had to “defend.”

Total mentions from the moderator and the two candidates combined for ISIS were 24; Russia/Putin had 16 and Iran 19. Total mentions of abortion, poverty, health insurance, LGBTQ rights and voter suppression were zero. Climate change was only mentioned—once—because Clinton brought it up.

As FAIR noted previously, in nine Democratic Party debates, there were no questions asked about poverty. As Think Progress pointed out, there were also zero questions about abortion.

Issues specifically affecting the poor, LGBTQ people and women (aside from a question about Trump denying that Clinton had “a presidential look”) continue to be overlooked. To the extent race was discussed, it was framed with the false parity of “race relations.” Holt didn’t ask Clinton, for example, how she would fight racism—a word Holt never mentioned—but instead asked her how she would “heal the divide.” (In Holt’s defense, he did press Trump on his racist “birther” campaign.)

The next debate will be on October 9, hosted by ABC’s Martha Raddatz, a reporter noted for her closeness to military sources (FAIR Blog, 11/14/11).


Adam Johnson is a contributing analyst for FAIR.org. You can follow him onTwitter at @AdamJohnsonNYC.

You can send messages to NBC News  via Twitter: @NBCNews.  Please remember that respectful communication is the most effective.

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


More Stories


  • New Mexico Exalts “Three Peoples” – and Leaves Blacks Out Entirely
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley and Glen Ford
    New Mexico Exalts “Three Peoples” – and Leaves Blacks Out Entirely
    27 Apr 2020
    In a recent article, Dr Natasha Howard, a lecturer in Africana Studies at the University of New Mexico, cited the campus’s “Three Peoples” mural as exemplifying the state
  • The Black "Progress Narrative" is Self-Defeating
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley and Glen Ford
    The Black "Progress Narrative" is Self-Defeating
    27 Apr 2020
    “When we think we’ve made progress, we are blinded to the ways we have not,” and wind up affirming our slave-like relationship to power, said Anthony Farley, a Visiting Profes
  • Group Demands Louisiana Prisons Be “Evacuated”
    Black Agenda Radio with Margaret Kimberley and Glen Ford
    Group Demands Louisiana Prisons Be “Evacuated”
    27 Apr 2020
    “The coronavirus is a death sentence on Black people,” who make up two-thirds of Louisiana’s prisoners, said Belinda Parker Brown, head of Louisiana United International.
  • Letters from Our Readers 
    Jahan Choudhry BAR Comments Editor
    Letters from Our Readers 
    24 Apr 2020
    The coup in Bolivia and the Bernie Sanders campaign were in your thoughts this week.
  • Diseased System in Shut-Lockdown: Never a Better Time to Fight for Socialism
    Glen Ford, BAR Executive Editor
    Diseased System in Shut-Lockdown: Never a Better Time to Fight for Socialism
    23 Apr 2020
    The current health and economic crisis will dramatically accelerate the processes of corporate monopolization, finance capital dictatorship, and working class precarity and immiseration.
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us