Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Loretta Lynch's Shame: International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda
Ann Garrison, BAR contributor
04 Feb 2015
🖨️ Print Article

Loretta Lynch's Shame: International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda

by Ann Garrison

This article previously appeared in Black Star News.

“They really were engaged in a political exercise to justify the military dictatorship established by Paul Kagame.”

News outlets have been praising Loretta Lynch's credentials as a former Special Counsel to the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda (ICTR); Bloomberg News praised the nominee's moral fiber in a report titled "Rwanda Tribunal Taught Loretta Lynch Real Power of Prosecutors." Those who know the disgraceful history of victor's justice at the ICTR, and its service to the US/NATO agenda in Africa and the rest of the Global South, are aware of this. For in-depth documentation and analysis, read "Justice Belied: The Unbalanced Scales of International Criminal Justice" by ICTR defense attorneys Sébastien Chartrand and John Philpot, from Baraka Books.

Last November 8th was the 20th anniversary of UN Resolution 955, which created the ICTR. To coincide with that anniversary, the UN announced a new ICTR legacy website, including a video tribute to itself.

During its 20 years in operation, the court indicted 93 Rwandan Hutus, convicted 61 and spent two billion dollars. In 2003, former Chief Prosecutor Carla Del Ponte announced that she intended to indict Rwanda’s Tutsi president, Paul Kagame, for the assassination of his predecessor, Rwandan Hutu President Juvenal Habyarimana, and Burundian Hutu President Cyprien Ntaryamira; but instead, Del Ponte was summarily fired.

No one was ever indicted for the assassinations, which, by the ICTR’s own admission, on its Youtube video post, "shattered the fragile peace established by the Arusha Accords, brokered in the hope of ending the armed conflict between the Rwandan Patriotic Front and the Rwandan Government."

Here is the opening self-congratulation of the ICTR's video tribute to itself:

"Its first makeshift courtroom, the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda went to work on a formidable task. Its mission: to locate, apprehend and prosecute the architects of the genocide. Over the last 20 years, the Tribunal delivered judgments that defined, for the first time, how the world confronts acts of genocide in a court of law."

“It was victor’s justice.”

The Taylor Report, on CIUT 89.5 FM Toronto, was for many years the only English language broadcast covering dissident history of the 1990 to 1994 war in Rwanda and the ICTR, so I asked Taylor Report host Phil Taylor what he thought of the video.  

"I think it’s shocking, embarrassing that they did this," he said. "You know, there’s a proverb that says, 'Self-praise is no recommendation.' What I saw was a self-promoting video. It’s totally inaccurate, and they end up, strangely, by seeming to endorse the current government of Rwanda. And I don’t understand how that has anything to do with the mandate of a tribunal, which was to look into the crimes committed in Rwanda in 1994.

"So it shows to me that they really were engaged in a political exercise to basically justify the regime that exists there today, which is a military dictatorship established by Paul Kagame masquerading as a political structure. I think it’s contemptible, when you see such absurd, grand talk about the tribunal, and you hear this actor’s voice – and I’m convinced that is an actor – somebody paid a lot of money for that four-minute, self-promoting video."

I told Phil that the video post does indeed acknowledge that it’s narrated by American television actor Clarke Peters, and produced by a New York City video production company.  

 Phil said it probably cost a lot of money.  Indeed.    

He also said that "to bring it down to saying that now, in Rwanda, you can listen to the radio and be safe – that is such a caricature, because it is widely known that if you were a broadcaster in Rwanda today, and you were supporting Victoire Ingabire, you would be arrested, and you would not be safe."

"Here is the United Nations International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda putting out propaganda to sustain a one-man dictatorship. That is a disgrace. And that people calling themselves lawyers and judges associate themselves with such a video really just tells you that it was bankrupt from the day it started.

"So, indeed it was, exactly what they said it would not be. It was victor’s justice. And the video that they presented is the kind of thing you get from an authoritarian regime. They do not expect to be contradicted. They don’t expect anybody to be allowed to say anything, except themselves.

"It’s like a regime – the ICTR. And it’s a self-congratulating regime. I don’t understand why they have a public relations department to slap them on the back. That seems to be a waste of money and not the purpose of a tribunal."

Whatever good reasons there may be to confirm Loretta Lynch's appointment as US Attorney General, this disgraceful episode of her legal career should not go unreported. And, it should not be reported in the same smug, self-congratulatory tone of the ICTR's 20th anniversary video. 

Oakland writer Ann Garrison writes for the San Francisco Bay View, Black Agenda Report, the Black Star News,Counterpunch, Colored Opinions,, and her own website, Ann Garrison, and produces for AfrobeatRadio on WBAI-NYC, KPFA Evening News,KPFA Flashpoints, and for her own YouTube Channel, AnnieGetYourGang. She can be reached at ann@afrobeatradio.com. In March 2014 she was awarded the Victoire Ingabire Umuhoza Democracy and Peace Prize for promoting peace in the Great Lakes Region of Africa through her reporting.

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


More Stories


  • Deportation of African and Other Black Immigrants Is Quietly Increasing And No One Is Taking Note
    12 Apr 2017
    by David Love “Fully one-third of immigrants, refugees and asylum seekers are African” – the fastest growing immigrant group -- and deportations of Black immigrants are expected to soar under Trump…
  • Remembering South African Struggle Hero Chris Hani: Lessons for Today
    12 Apr 2017
    by Arianna Lissoni South African communist leader Chris Hani was assassinated by white racists 27 years ago, removing him from the scene during the nation’s transition to Black rule. Hani fought…
  • Capitalism, Racism and the History of South Africa
    12 Apr 2017
    by Sehlare Makgetlaneng The African National Congress has failed to nationalize industries, redistribute the land, or tackle other goals of the Freedom Charter. Instead, it deliberately created a…
  • History: How African Muslims “Civilized Spain”
    12 Apr 2017
    by Garikai Chengu For most of human history, northern Europe was a barbarian realm, to which it reverted with the fall of Rome. Muslim Moors from Africa civilized Spain. “In the 10th century,…
  • Black Agenda Radio for Week of April 10, 2017
    11 Apr 2017
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us