Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Freedom Rider: Desmond Tutu Silenced
Margaret Kimberley, BAR editor and senior columnist
10 Oct 2007
🖨️ Print Article

Freedom Rider: Desmond Tutu Silenced

by BAR editor and senior columnist Margaret
Kimberley

"Perhaps more sinister is why is there no outcry in the
United States about theFRIntifada Israeli siege in the West Bank? You see the harrowing
images of what suicide bombers have done, something we all condemn, but we see
no scenes of what the tanks are doing to Palestinian homes and people." - Archbishop
Desmond Tutu
, 2002

Aside from the Bushite assaults on civil
liberties, there is another dangerous threat to free speech in this country.
That threat falls on anyone who dares to criticize the Israeli government or
America's foreign policy towards Israel. Simply put, there is no right to free
speech where discussion of Israel is concerned. Critics of Israel are censored
and silenced, regardless of prior reputation or professional standing.

Archbishop Desmond Tutu won the Nobel Peace prize in 1986
for his efforts to peacefully end apartheid in his South African homeland. He
served for many years as Archbishop of Cape Town and is one of the most highly
respected Christian clergyman in the world. Tutu recently returned from a fact
finding mission to Darfur that also included Jimmy Carter.

"There is
no right to free speech where discussion of Israel is concerned."

None of the accolades, honors, or awards
bestowed on Tutu over the years were enough to protect him from the power of
the pro-Israeli lobby. Tutu was invited to speak at the University of St.
Thomas in St. Paul, Minnesota. The event, scheduled to take place in the spring
of 2008, was sponsored by a youth group dedicated to practicing non-violence.

What followed has now become all too familiar.
The university president, Father Dennis Dease, withdrew the invitation after a
local organization, the Jewish Community Relations Council of Minnesota and the
Dakotas, protested. The JCRC said that Jews were "hurt" about Tutu's comments
on Israel. Father Dennis Dease, the university president, uses this
claimed hurt as his reason for canceling
the speech
.

FRCarterBook
The JCRC and Father Dease falsely claim that in
a 2002 speech Tutu compared Israel to Hitler's Germany. That assertion is a
lie. Tutu said no such thing. He did point out that powerful nations can fall.
"The apartheid government was very powerful, but today it no longer
exists. Hitler, Mussolini, Stalin, Pinochet, Milosovic, and Idi Amin were all
powerful, but in the end they bit the dust."

The meaning of Tutu's words are clear to anyone who is
interested in honest intellectual debate. The Israeli lobby has no such
interest. Their goal is to silence Israel's critics. They may deny tenure to
academics such as Norman Finkelstein, or make certain that Stephen Walt, John
Mearsheimer and Jimmy Carter are all denied venues to speak or promote their
books. The cowardly acquiescence by the University of St. Thomas was obviously
due to direct political pressure and fear of future repercussions.

"The
Israeli lobby's goal is to silence Israel's critics."

DePaul University behaved in a similar manner
when they were lobbied to deny tenure to Norman Finkelstein. It didn't matter
that Norman Finkelstein is himself Jewish, and the son of holocaust survivors.
He is an outspoken critic of the Israeli government and of efforts to use past
Jewish suffering to gain political and economic advantage, which he documents
in his ground breaking book The Holocaust Industry.
He described his situation and presciently that of Tutu with the University of
St. Thomas:

". . . the university
found itself forced to choose between ‘a long-term catastrophe and a short-term
catastrophe' - the short-term catastrophe being the publicity about his case,
the long-term catastrophe ‘having me on this faculty for another 20 years, and
every time I open my mouth or say something about Israeli policy, the hysteria
starting up again, and they see their money disappear.' "

"The hurt
of white supremacist hate speech wasn't an issue."

Because of the fear of disappearing money and
political support that every university needs, Jewish "hurt" supersedes
everyone else's.

The University of St. Thomas has no problem
inviting speakers who openly express beliefs that hurt other groups. The
internment of Japanese Americans during World War II was certainly hurtful to
them. Yet after writing a hate filled screed, In Defense of Internment,
right wing propagandist Michelle Malkin
spoke
at the University of St. Thomas. The hurt of white supremacist hate
speech wasn't an issue with Father Dease or other university officials.

Archbishop Tutu should directly address this
assault on his reputation. He should not only refute the lies told about him
but he should also force the university to respond. They think they are off the
hook because the event will be held at another school in St. Paul. Tutu should
make it clear that moving him across town will not silence him. His voice is
respected and it is sorely needed. The influence of one group will do even more
damage to this country and to the world if it is not confronted.

Margaret Kimberley's
Freedom Rider column appears weekly in BAR. Ms. Kimberley lives in New York
City, and can be reached via e-Mail at
Margaret.Kimberley(at)BlackAgandaReport.Com. Ms. Kimberley' maintains an
edifying and frequently updated blog at 
freedomrider.blogspot.com.  More of her work
is also available at her Black Agenda Report
archive
page.

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


More Stories


  • President Maduro holding up a map of Venezuela and the Essequibo region
    Andreína Chávez Alava
    Presidents of Guyana and Venezuela to Hold Summit on Essequibo Dispute
    13 Dec 2023
    Brazil’s Lula, along with leaders from CELAC and CARICOM, will facilitate the talks between Caracas and Georgetown to promote peace in the region.
  • Children walking through rubble in Gaza
    Steve Salaita
    Scrolling Through Genocide
    13 Dec 2023
    Zionist massacres are livestreamed to the masses in high definition and still nobody can stop them.
  • close-up image of Frank Chapman in a checkered shirt
    Frank Chapman
    A Word on the Meaning of Political Self-Empowerment for Our Movement
    13 Dec 2023
    Frank Chapman wrote this statement to call for unity in struggle by Black, Latino and working-class communities.
  • Jill Stein campaign
    Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
    Dr. Jill Stein: A Ballot Challenge to the Crimes of Empire
    06 Dec 2023
    Dr. Jill Stein stepped up to compete for the Green Party presidential nomination after Dr. Cornel West decided to run as an independent. Ann Garrison spoke to her for Pacifica Radio’s “Capitalism,…
  • Alan Pelaez Lopez
    Roberto Sirvent, BAR Book Forum Editor
    BAR Book Forum: Alan Pelaez Lopez’s Book, “When Language Broke Open”
    06 Dec 2023
    In this series, we ask acclaimed authors to answer five questions about their book. This week’s featured author is Alan Pelaez Lopez. Dr. Lopez is an assistant professor at the University of…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us