Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

“Humanitarian Aid” at Gunpoint Isn't Humanitarian
Bill Quigley
21 May 2008
🖨️ Print Article

“Humanitarian
Aid” at Gunpoint Isn't Humanitarian

By
Mel Reeves

The
esteemed newspaper of record The New York Times ran an editorial last
week, written by Robert D. Kaplan, entitled “Aid
at the point of a gun.
” It recommended a “humanitarian
invasion” of Myanmar (Burma) by US military forces “...as part of
a coalition including France, Australia and other Western powers...”
The invasion's pretext would be to deliver badly needed aid to the
victims of Cyclone Nargis, aid which that country's government has
been reluctant to accept on the terms favored by its donors.

With
the folks who say they want to help Myanmar declaring their
willingness to use force to get it done, that country's government
appears somewhat justified in its caution. Without a hint of
conscious irony, the NY times editorial calls the Myanmar government
“the most morally bankrupt on earth.”

The
French initially proposed this idea, testing the waters. But Mr.
Kaplan is quite serious and takes it a step further, insisting that a
humanitarian invasion is “militarily doable” and that “...the
challenge would be politics both inside Myanmar and
internationally.” Kaplan suggests the deed be executed in
coalition with France and others, with UN if possible. So while he
should be given credit for checking with others, he left out the most
important consideration: national sovereignty, the right of Myanmar's
people to determine their own destiny.

usmc_expeditonary_force01Kaplan
explains that “...a humanitarian invasion could ultimately lead to
the regimes collapse and we would have to accept responsibility for
the regimes collapse...” In plain language this spokesman for
empire, this right wing ideologue is talking about invading a
sovereign country and dividing up the spoils. The remainder of the
editorial is spent wondering how this can be done cleanly, without
repeating the historic disaster of Iraq.

The
US humanitarian mission to bring democracy to that unhappy country
has them living in the dark; literally, since the US bombed most of
the electrical grids and other sources of power and has yet to fully
repair them. The humanitarian mission in Iraq has resulted in the
deaths of hundreds of thousands of Iraqis and displaced hundreds of
thousands more. Most Americans, who depend on the nightly News and
Big Business media to keep them informed, don't know that two million
Iraqis are homeless, a million inside the country's borders and
another million in exile abroad.

Perhaps
this is the same humanitarian impulse US commanders manifested toward
troops of the Iraqi Republican Guard after they had conceded defeat,
hoisted white flags and assumed nonthreatening postures while they
withdrew homeward in February of 1991. Instead tens
of thousands
of Iraqis were massacred on a 60 mile stretch of
what is now called the “Highway of Death”. US forces employed a
combination of cluster bombs and other incendiary weapons to kill
tens of thousands of non-resisting Iraqi soldiers in what some pilots
at the time called a “turkey shoot.”

In
Afghanistan US “humanitarianism” led to the restoration of the
opium poppy crop as the mainstay of that country's economy, after the
Taliban had successfully suppressed the growing and export of opium.
Now there are reports of US invaders using the poppy crop to pay off
the gangsters who side with them against the Taliban.

The
embattled Rev. Jeremiah Wright was roundly criticized for one of his
sermons in which he condemned the so-called humanitarian invasion of
Panama to rid it of  the Pentagon's business partner Manuel Noriega. The
invasion resulted of in the deaths of hundreds
of innocent Panamanians.

The
make believe moral high ground on which the US government stands has
never existed.

Some
influential establishment forces, publicists and politicians feel
that Darfur could use a little
bit
of that same aggressive humanitarianism. But this
government’s humanitarianism is determined by what’s in it for
them. An invasion is an invasion, regardless of “humanitarian”
pretenses. An intervention in Darfur because it could possibly
double the Darfur’s trouble.

If
there is any real humanitarianism in the US, we could use it on the
Gulf Coast, where victims of Hurricane Katrina are re-victimized as
the government refuses to rebuild the poorer sections of the city, as
well as the needed infrastructure, including public schools and
hospitals, while allowing corporate profiteers to take advantage of
the disaster. We could use it too, in other inner cities, where
people are sleeping on the streets and living in substandard housing
and sending children to substandard public schools. A real
humanitarian deployment, if there is such a thing, would be more than
welcome at home, where we are militarizing and extending the border
to every city, town and workplace, chasing after so-called illegals
like they are animals, hunting them down on the job, breaking into
their houses because they seek economic prosperity in this country.
It would be nice. But nobody's holding breath waiting for any of
this.

And
now we are supposed to believe that these same folks want to go to
war to help someone.

Mel Reeves is an activist living in Miami. He
can be contacted at mellaneous19@yahoo.com

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


More Stories


  • Dr. Marsha Coleman-Adebayo , BAR editor and columnist
    Margaret Flowers’ Retrospective on Running as a Green for the U.S. Senate
    08 Nov 2016
    by BAR editor and columnist Dr. Marsha Adebayo The major parties are more concerned with preserving their duopoly than with defeating each other. So-called “progressives” help preserve duopoly rule,…
  • Raymond Nat Turner , BAR poet-in-residence
    Tuesday Takeout
    08 Nov 2016
    by BAR poet in residence Raymond Nat Turner Terror Tuesday is what the White House calls the basement meetings at which the First Black President profiles and targets individuals and groups of people…
  • Bryan K. Bullock
    Black American Anti-Imperialism: an Invisible Subject for the New York Times
    08 Nov 2016
    by Bryan K. Bullock To read the foreign policy pages of the New York Times is to enter a world of whiteness. “Whites are the only ones who are presumed to have an opinion on such issues that is worth…
  • Ann Garrison , BAR contributor
    Clinton Is the Most Dangerous Person Alive – An Interview with Edward S. Herman
    08 Nov 2016
    by Ann Garrison The just-concluded election revealed as much about the corporate media, which has broken every rule of journalism to support Hillary Clinton, and the fraudulence of much of the…
  • CTU Reaches out
    Leah Fried
    In Chicago, Teachers and Black Lives Matter Activists Partner to Build a Bigger Movement
    08 Nov 2016
    When the Chicago Teachers Union goes on strike, it doesn’t walk alone; Movement 4 Black Lives organizations have their back. And, when young Black activists campaign against police terror, the…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us