Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Freedom Rider: Political Snobbery
Margaret Kimberley, BAR editor and senior columnist
04 Nov 2010
🖨️ Print Article

by BAR editor and senior columnist Margaret Kimberley

Increasingly, the Democratic Party is a near-empty vessel. Democrats “look down their noses at Tea Partiers with misspelled words on their signs but exalt Clinton era drug enforcement policies which filled the jails and the enactment of NAFTA and welfare ‘reform.’” Motivated more by prejudice than political substance, Democrats “rarely express opposition to any action, no matter how awful, if Democrats are behind it.”

 

Freedom Rider: Political Snobbery

by BAR editor and senior columnist Margaret Kimberley

“Democratic presidents have taken positions identical to those of Republicans and yet their supporters seem not to notice or to care.”

Listening to most Democrats is akin to a former of auditory torture. They have nothing to offer in the way of true political discourse, and they have one constant refrain. “Anyone is better than the Republicans.” It doesn’t matter if Obama escalates war, keeps Guantanamo open, claims the right to assassinate American citizens, increases immigrant deportations, asks courts to uphold don’t ask don’t tell, allows the right wing to destroy ACORN, funnels trillions of dollars to Wall Street, and promises to undo the will of voters who want to decriminalize drug use. Nothing matters except keeping Republicans out of office.

Republicans are compared to everyone from Attila the Hun to Hitler. The very thought of their presence is supposed to inspire apathetic voters to head for the polls, suspend disbelief and keep voting for the party which treats them like chumps.

Closer inspection reveals something more disturbing, not about Republicans, but about Democrats. Most of them aren’t particularly concerned with the policy positions supported by their party. They rarely express opposition to any action, no matter how awful, if Democrats are behind it.

Most Americans, regardless of party affiliation, are proud believers that the state has the authority and the right to exert control over human life in this country and around the world. The end result is a rate of incarceration higher than in any country on earth and a military budget larger than that of every other nation combined. There are precious few citizens, Republicans or Democrats, who see anything wrong with this state of affairs.

“Most Democrats aren’t particularly concerned with the policy positions supported by their party.”

While Sarah Palin’s very name is used to turn her into a bogey woman who can frighten Democrats into toeing the party line, Obama’s administration actually varies very little from what would be offered by a Republican president. It is true that Sarah Palin is an intellectual lightweight. She makes up words such as “refrudiate” and writes notes on her hand like a middle school student surprised by a pop quiz. She is decidedly conservative and her endorsement was sought by the new crop of right wing Tea Party candidates seeking office.

Obama differs in every way. He is supposedly liberal, no one questions his intellectual grasp of the issues, but neither his acumen nor his party affiliation have inspired him to uphold progressive positions. He was a constitutional law professor, but in office he has asked courts to uphold Bush era decisions on surveillance and he has chosen to protect his predecessor from prosecution of any crimes. He has asserted his right to assassinate American citizens for any reason he deems necessary. Could civil libertarians be any worse off with a dumb Republican president? When a federal court ordered the military to stop enforcing the anti-gay don’t ask, don’t tell policy, the Obama administration went to court seeking permission to continue enforcing a rule it claims to want to do away with. Could gay rights activists be any worse off with a conservative Republican in the White House?

Barack Obama and his Democratic predecessor Bill Clinton were loved in part because they were the “right” kind of people. They came from the best schools, law school graduates of Harvard and Yale. Obama was president of the Harvard Law Review and Clinton was a Rhodes scholar. Their backgrounds are contrasted with Palin‘s lack of achievement, but did their intellects really make for a better, or more humane government?

“Could civil libertarians be any worse off with a dumb Republican president?”

In case after case, Democratic presidents have taken positions identical to those of Republicans and yet their supporters seem not to notice or to care. If a Democrat with the right credentials sends the nation and the world on the road to hell, party loyalists never question them.

Should Sarah Palin become president we would hear endless jokes about her stupidity, and her daughter’s teenage motherhood, and the baby’s daddy, and her inarticulateness. Democrats would moan and groan that the president was dumb and preceded in office by a smart man who wrote his own speeches.

Simply put, most Democratic political attitudes are based on little more than class snobbery. They look down their noses at Tea Partiers with misspelled words on their signs but exalt Clinton era drug enforcement policies which filled the jails and the enactment of NAFTA and welfare “reform.” He and Obama were the total package, representing the nation’s elite, complete with equally smart trophy wives. Image is enough to silence the faithful.

It is easy to sneer at Sarah Palin who hunts wolves, claims to see Russia from her house, and will soon star in a reality television show. Apparently it is hard to see that Obama’s health care reform is a giveaway to the health insurance industry and that he actively sabotaged both the Copenhagen conference on climate change and the Durban II conference on racism. Most progressives will hotly proclaim the importance of either or both of those issues in the making of their ideology, but most would be unaware of or staunchly defend their idol’s decision to actively oppose them on issues that are allegedly of importance.

The smarty pants Ivy Leaguer Democrats have no allegiance to their supporters and their duplicity cannot be forgiven or forgotten. There should be no reason to fear support for other parties or the damage that support may do to the Democrats who are not only useless to their supporters, but incompetent in maintaining popular support. It is time for real change, and that means a change in allegiance to the Democratic Party.

Margaret Kimberley's Freedom Rider column appears weekly in BAR, and is widely reprinted elsewhere. She maintains a frequently updated blog as well as at http://freedomrider.blogspot.com. Ms. Kimberley lives in New York City, and can be reached via e-Mail at Margaret.Kimberley(at)BlackAgandaReport.com.

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


More Stories


  • Sikivu Hutchinson
    In Cold Blood: The Murder of Renisha McBride
    12 Nov 2013
    by Sikivu Hutchinson The 19-year-old Black woman had just gotten a job at the Ford Motor Company when she was shot in the face with a shotgun by a white homeowner after seeking help after a car crash…
  • Iyanna Jones
    No Fear: The Marsha Coleman Adebayo Story Green Lit for Pre-Production
    12 Nov 2013
    by Iyanna Jones The gripping personal saga of the struggle that led to passage of the No FEAR Act will soon begin film production. No Fear: The Marsha Coleman-Adebayo Story, reveals the venality,…
  • Paul Street
    Obama as the “New JFK”: Nothing Great to Be
    12 Nov 2013
    by Paul Street As the anniversary of President John F. Kennedy’s assassination approaches, the media will be awash with comparisons between JFK and Barack Obama. The two do, indeed, have much in…
  • Ama Biney
    Marking 15 Years Since the Passing of Kwame Ture: Speeches and Interviews
    12 Nov 2013
    by Dr. Ama Biney Kwame Ture, formerly known as Stokely Carmichael, the former SNCC activist whose name will forever be linked to the term “Black Power,” died in Conakry, Guinea, on November 15, 1998…
  • Sean Posey
    Racially Engineering the Pseudo-White Barbie
    12 Nov 2013
    by Sean Posey Black is definitely no longer considered beautiful in the world marketed to us by corporate media. The Black aesthetic has been Barbied out of the marketplace. For example, “Implants,…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us