Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire
  • omnibus

The Little-Known International Charter At The Center of Ukraine War and China's Future Defense
Jacqueline Luqman
27 Apr 2022
The Little-Known International Charter At The Center of Ukraine War and China's Future Defense
Russian president Boris Yeltsin and U.S. president Bill Clinton at the 1999 OSCE summit in Istanbul (Photo: Belga)

The U.S. talks about "rule based order" because international law is not on its side. The 1999 OSCE Charter explains why the Biden administration would rather make up a new phrase out of whole cloth than live up to agreements it signed.

In 1999, the United States and the 56 other participating states of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) signed a charter in Instanbul that is another intentionally ignored key to understanding the war in Ukraine.

The OSCE is the world’s largest regional security organization. It claims to engage in political dialogue - that is, a forum for political dialogue on a wide range of security issues. There are 57 OSCE member states that cover three continents - North America, Europe and Asia. The policies the OSCE deliberates over include security issues such as arms control, terrorism, good governance, energy security, human trafficking, democratization, media freedom, and the rights of national minorities that affect more than a billion people. This is what they say they do, anyway.

But the 1999 Instanbul Charter signed by all the member states says that countries should be free to choose their own security arrangements and alliances but specifies that, in doing so, countries "will not strengthen their security at the expense of the security of other states."

This charter was raised as the rationale for Russia mobilizing troops inside its border in response to US and it western allies expanding NATO eastward since the Cold War and refusing to rule out granting membership to Ukraine. NATO says it is a defensive alliance that is open to new members, but can we be honest - because we always are - and point out that Russia was not doing anything in Ukraine or anywhere else to put NATO on the defensive. This issue of the charter being violated was raised by Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov in February 2022 when he had a phone conversation with US Secretary of State Anthony Blinken.

"Our western colleagues are simply trying not even to ignore but to consign to oblivion this key principle of international law agreed in the Euro-Atlantic space," Lavrov said at the time. "We will insist on an honest conversation and an honest explanation of why the West doesn't want to fulfill its obligations or wants to meet them only selectively to its own advantage."

Lavrov had written to the United States, Canada, and a number of governments on January 28, 2022, to ask them urgently to explain how they intended to fulfill this commitment to the principle of "indivisible security" that they all agreed to in the 1999 OSCE Istanbul Charter. What Russia received, instead of answers to its questions or discussions about the West holding up its end of the charter agreement, were US and NATO demands that Russia pull back troops from inside its own borders.

This happened in February 2022, right around the same time that Biden started claiming that Russia was going to invade Ukraine “ANY DAY NOW!!!” The whole time, however, Russia was trying to get the US to adhere to the OSCE charter. But it seems that the US was really just pushing for this war.

So when Chinese President Xi Jinping announced a "global security initiative" that upholds the principle of "indivisible security," it’s odd that Reuters - the same outlet that reported on Russia’s Lavrov trying to get the US to adhere to the OSCE charter in February - characterized the idea of indivisible security as some mysterious thing that Xi just came up with. In fact, it is literally what the 1999 OSCE charter is based on!

Reuters goes on to inexplicably say that Xi’s proposal is one also endorsed by Russia but said that Xi gave no details of how it would be implemented. Well, not only is the concept of “indivisible security” endorsed by Russia, it was an agreement signed by 57 member countries of the OSCE in 1999.

And Xi doesn’t have to give details on how the proposal would be implemented because those details already exist in the 1999 OSCE Istanbul Charter. China is not a member state of the OSCE, but is raising the issue of the organization's violation of its own charter to not only point out the hypocrisy of the US/EU/NATO in this horror they created in Ukraine, but also to make its  case for defending itself against further US imperialist aggression in Taiwan.

Li Mingjiang, associate professor at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies in Singapore, is quoted by Reuters saying, "If China deems actions by U.S. and its allies on Taiwan or the South China Sea as disregarding its security concerns, it could evoke the concept of 'indivisible security' to claim the moral high ground in retaliation." And Wang Jiangyu, a law professor at the City University of Hong Kong, said that by evoking the concept of "indivisible security," which had originated from Europe, China could hope to make its actions in defense of its core interests appear more legitimate to other countries.

Security for Europe but not for Russia or China? Xi Jingping is saying that this is not how it should work. And it should not. As Lavrov tried to point out but was completely dismissed by Antony Blinken, no country should have its security concerns violated by another country claiming defense while actually building up its own security. The 1999 OSCE Istanbul Charter says that.

But the way the Reuters article reads, China has concocted some strange thing no one has ever heard of, that they’re being tight-lipped and secretive about, even though Xi is literally using language and concepts already established by the OSCE and agreed to by the US and its Western allies. But the US will ignore China’s invocation of the indivisible security model of the OSCE, and claim it's a sneaky Chinese provocation.

Just like they did with Russia regarding Ukraine.

Jacqueline Luqman is co-host of By Any Means Necessary on Radio Sputnik. She is also a contributor to The Real News Network, Editor-In-Chief of the social media program Luqman Nation, and a contributor to Black Power Media. She has more than 20 years of activism in Washington, DC focusing on participating in and supporting community-level issues as well as regional and national issues that impact working-class, poor, and oppressed people in the US and abroad. She is a member of the Black Alliance for Peace, Pan-African Community Action, is a supporter of several other grassroots radical Black-focused and led organizations, and is an active member of the Board of Social Action in Plymouth Congregational United Church of Christ, a progressive church in Washington, DC.

OSCE
Russia
Ukraine
China

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles. Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

U.S. Effort to Hurt Russia Undermines Itself and the World
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
U.S. Effort to Hurt Russia Undermines Itself and the World
08 June 2022
The U.S. drive to dominate creates self-inflicted wounds and self-imposed crises.
Why the Belt and Road Initiative Won’t be Derailed by the Ukraine Crisis
Danny Haiphong, BAR Contributing Editor
Why the Belt and Road Initiative Won’t be Derailed by the Ukraine Crisis
08 June 2022
Ukraine has been at the center of a massive geopolitical and economic whirlwind.
The Indo-Pacific Economic Framework and the Decline of the American Empire
Danny Haiphong, BAR Contributing Editor
The Indo-Pacific Economic Framework and the Decline of the American Empire
03 June 2022
The Indo-Pacific Economic Framework (IPEF) for Prosperity is another futile U.S. effort to diminish China's economic prowess.
Fact Finding Mission to Donbass
John Parker
Fact Finding Mission to Donbass
18 May 2022
John Parker is the Socialist Unity Party candidate for U.S.
BAR Book Forum: Gao Yunxiang’s “Arise Africa! Roar China!”
Roberto Sirvent, BAR Book Forum Editor
BAR Book Forum: Gao Yunxiang’s “Arise Africa! Roar China!”
11 May 2022
In this series, we ask acclaimed authors to answer five questions about their book.
To Honor Odessa Anti-Fascists, Stop Weapons to Ukraine!
John Parker
To Honor Odessa Anti-Fascists, Stop Weapons to Ukraine!
11 May 2022
Statement by John Parker, Socialist Unity Party candidate for U.S.
No to a New Monroe Doctrine in the Pacific
Carlos Martinez
No to a New Monroe Doctrine in the Pacific
11 May 2022
The U.S. and Australia have fiercely opposed the new security agreement between China and the Solomon Islands.
The Poor Peoples Campaign Dishonors Martin Luther King
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
The Poor Peoples Campaign Dishonors Martin Luther King
04 May 2022
It is disheartening to hear movement leaders say they are inspired by Martin Luther King while also supporting the U.S.
U.S. Corporate Media Watch: An Interview with Richard Medhurst
Roberto Sirvent, Richard Medhurst
U.S. Corporate Media Watch: An Interview with Richard Medhurst
04 May 2022
“U.S. Corporate Media Watch: An Interview with Richard Medhurst” Richard Medhurst and Roberto Sirvent
The Sports World’s Selective Moral Indignation
Gus Griffin
The Sports World’s Selective Moral Indignation
03 May 2022
Russian athletes have been banned from the Boston Marathon, Wimbledon tennis championships, and perhaps the next Olympic games.

More Stories


  • The January 6th Scam
    Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
    The January 6th Scam
    22 Jun 2022
    Democrats are using the hearings investigating the January 6, 2021 attack on the Capitol as one long campaign commercial. They believe that saying the name Trump often enough will inspire disap
  • INTERVIEW: Mrs. Fannie Lou Hamer by Jack O’Dell, 1965
    Editors, The Black Agenda Review
    INTERVIEW: Mrs. Fannie Lou Hamer by Jack O’Dell, 1965
    22 Jun 2022
    A 1965 Freedomways interview with Mrs. Fannie Lou Hamer provides an unvarnished and unsentimental portrait of Mississippi – and of the tasks of the Freedom Movement.
  • Eritrean Martyrs' Day
    Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor
    Eritrean Martyrs' Day
    22 Jun 2022
    Eritrea emerged as an independent nation after decades of struggle. It celebrates Martyrs' Day in honor of those who paid the ultimate price.
  •  BAR Book Forum: Shanté Paradigm Smalls’s “Hip Hop Heresies”
    Roberto Sirvent, BAR Book Forum Editor
    BAR Book Forum: Shanté Paradigm Smalls’s “Hip Hop Heresies”
    22 Jun 2022
    This week’s featured author is Shanté Paradigm Smalls. Smalls is Associate Professor of Black Studies in the Department of English and Faculty in Critical Race & Ethnic Studies at St. John’s…
  • Celebrations in Colombia’s Streets: Gustavo Petro to Be First Left-Wing President and Francia Márquez the First Afro-Descendant Woman VP
    Julie Varughese
    Celebrations in Colombia’s Streets: Gustavo Petro to Be First Left-Wing President and Francia Márquez the First Afro-Descendant Woman VP
    22 Jun 2022
    The Historical Pact candidates Gustavo Petro and Francia Marquez were elected President and Vice President of Colombia. Their victory is the first for leftists in that country but part of a trend in…
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us