Black Agenda Report
Black Agenda Report
News, commentary and analysis from the black left.

  • Home
  • Africa
  • African America
  • Education
  • Environment
  • International
  • Media and Culture
  • Political Economy
  • Radio
  • US Politics
  • War and Empire

Black Workers and Immigrants: Borrow a Page from Marx
Ken Morgan
15 Aug 2018
🖨️ Print Article

“Marx blamed the rulers of colonialism and those that exploited Irish workers for lower wages when they got to England, and not the exploited Irish worker.”

Tom Broadwater, a brother, recently wrote a commentary titled “Democrats’ Immigration Dogma is Damaging African American Communities.” It appeared in the Afro American newspaper and in Newsweek.

He says, “No American should lose their job because an employer wants to hire lower-cost foreign workers.” He criticized Bernie Sanders’ group “Our Revolution” for firing its “National Justice” director who is part black and part Latina. She pointed out that excessive immigration can hurt low-wage American workers.

Broadwater copies President Trump’s charges that immigrants steal American jobs. He said, “They’re taking our jobs. They’re taking our manufacturing jobs. They’re taking our money. They’re killing us.”

Trump is a member of the ruling class, who seeks to maintain and strengthen its domain, as is Bernie Sanders. They take different paths to preserve capitalism and the ruling class’s interest. It’s all about the 1% to 10%, who owns a good proportion of the wealth and means of production.

Part of Trump’s “Make American Great Again” package, in addition to keeping jobs in the U.S., is to prevent immigrants from taking jobs. Too many of the white working class fell into the trap and got Trump elected over these things. We blacks should not fall into the same mode.

“The ruling classes by hook and crook sought to maintain these divisions.”

Worker exploitation, racism, sexism, and homophobia will always remain as long as capitalism exists. Malcolm X said, “You can't have capitalism without racism.” I add that these things live with or without immigration. They all adversely affect African Americans and immigrants, who are mostly people of color.

Borrow a page from Karl Marx, who wrote about the importing of Irish workers to England. It pushed English workers’ wages down. Marx’s main point was that this occurrence mainly drove a wedge between English and Irish workers under capitalism.

For the English worker, the immigrant was a low-life sent to compete for native jobs that lowered the living standards of the English worker. The ruling classes by hook and crook sought to maintain this division. It is a division that weakened the working class. Does this scenario sound familiar today?

Trump and Broadwater, as opposed to Marx, are looking at it through different lenses. Marx blamed the rulers of colonialism and those that exploited Irish workers for lower wages when they got to England, and not the exploited Irish worker.

Demand a $15 an hour minimum wage for all now. Create public service jobs to fix the U.S. infrastructure. Amnesty for all immigrants.

Dr. Ken Morgan is a black activist and scholar. He can be reached at kmorgan2408@comcast.net.

Immigration

Do you need and appreciate Black Agenda Report articles? Please click on the DONATE icon, and help us out, if you can.


Related Stories

Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
White Supremacy and "Heritage Americans"
18 November 2026
White supremacy periodically markets itself with new words. The Alt Right becomes MAGA, becomes Heritage Americans.
Black Alliance for Peace NYC/NJ Citywide Alliance
Collective Statement Delivered at Delaney Hall Rally - June 12, 2026
15 July 2026
Capitalist predation and imperialism displace people from their homelands. Once in the U.S.
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
The Obama Center is a Monument to the More Effective Evil
10 June 2026
Barack Obama bailed out the banks, deported millions, and devastated nations and millions of people through wars of aggression.
Community Movement Builders - Newark
CMB Newark Statement on the Delaney Hall Uprising
03 June 2026
The immigrants who revolted inside the Delaney Hall immigration jail are not criminals but prisoners of war, and their actions are those of res
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
Making America Whiter Again: White Supremacy in Action
27 May 2026
There is nothing mysterious about Trump’s effort to curb legal immigration. White supremacy is the explanation.
Ann Garrison, BAR Contributing Editor , Jamal Abdulahi
Trump is Not Defeated in Minnesota
27 May 2026
Minnesota pushed back against ICE until its visible presence seemed cut in half, but Trump does not forgive or forget, and it’s a tim
John Perry
Exaggerated Claims by White Nationalists About Latino Migration to US
06 May 2026
The same exaggerated numbers that buoy Trump's border panic also help US-funded NGOs attack socialist governments. 
Black Alliance For Peace
In Solidarity with the Prairieland Nine
25 March 2026
The Prairieland Nine convictions are an example of lawfare designed to criminalize political dissent and intimidate movements challenging the n
Boycott the world cup
Black Alliance For Peace
100 Days From the World Cup, an International Coalition is Calling on FIFA to Move the Games From the U.S.
11 March 2026
The US has disqualified itself from hosting the World Cup through wars, genocide, and domestic repression.
Margaret Kimberley, BAR Executive Editor and Senior Columnist
ICE Exposes Democratic Party Irrelevance
28 January 2026
The Democratic Party is useful only to the oligarch class, who give them their marching orders.

More Stories


  • BAR Co-Founder Book Exposes "Sham” of US Democracy
    Black Agenda Radio with Nellie Bailey and Glen Ford
    BAR Co-Founder Book Exposes "Sham” of US Democracy
    23 Dec 2019
    The US has failed in its purported mission to forge a society based on human equality, said Margaret Kimberley, co-founder of Black Agenda Report and author of the new book, “
  • McCarthy Era Laid Groundwork for Sixties Repression
    Black Agenda Radio with Nellie Bailey and Glen Ford
    McCarthy Era Laid Groundwork for Sixties Repression
    23 Dec 2019
    Charisse Burden Stelly, professor of Africana Studies and Political Science at Carleton College, said the long US history of red-baiting led to lethal repression of radicals in the
  • Democrats Largely Silent on Bolivia Coup
    Black Agenda Radio with Nellie Bailey and Glen Ford
    Democrats Largely Silent on Bolivia Coup
    23 Dec 2019
    “We’ve seen very little pushback from the Democratic Party” to the military coup that deposed Evo Morales’ Native American government, said Jake Johnston, of the Center for Ec
  • Letters from Our Readers 
    Jahan Choudhry BAR Comments Editor
    Letters from Our Readers 
    19 Dec 2019
    This week readers discussed police brutality and the Trump impeachment proceedings.  We share your letters for “
  • The Impending Ruling Class Mental Breakdown and Riot
    Glen Ford , BAR executive editor
    The Impending Ruling Class Mental Breakdown and Riot
    19 Dec 2019
    The outcome of the early primaries may erase Joe Biden’s “electability” luster and plunge the Lords of Capital into a panic in which all bets are off on what’s left of democratic liberties.
  • Load More
Subscribe
connect with us
about us
contact us