Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.  If you broadcast our audio commentaries please consider a recurring donation to Black Agenda Report.

Madame President? No, Madame Prisoner: Rwanda’s Victoire Ingabire

  • Sharebar
    Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version

    by Ann Garrison

    The Obama administration and its European allies lavish praise, weapons and money on Paul Kagame’s military and ethnic dictatorship in Rwanda. Meanwhile, Victoire Ingabire, a woman of peace, languishes in Kagame’s prisons. If she were president, “there would be a major change in how Rwandans and Congolese live as neighbors, because that would be the end of Rwanda invading Congo.”

    Madame President? No, Madame Prisoner: Rwanda’s Victoire Ingabire

    by Ann Garrison

    Why have President Obama and the U.S. State Department remained so silent about her case?”

    Nearly 60% of Rwanda’s Members of Parliament are women, and the country is commonly praised for empowering women. In October 2011, Rwandan President Paul Kagame’s delirious state newspaper even suggested that he deserved that year’s Nobel Peace Prize more than the three African women who won, because of his “good practices” to “guarantee a future devoid of gender imbalance.” Trouble with this theory is that Madame Victoire Ingabire, the one woman who dared to challenge Paul Kagame by attempting to run against him in 2010, has been in prison ever since. On Friday, December 13th, while Kagame was in South Africa to pay his last respects to Nelson Mandela, his Supreme Court upheld Victoire’s conviction and extended her sentence from eight to fifteen years.

    Rwanda’s Supreme Court justices, 42% of whom are women, agreed with the lower court’s ruling that Victoire conspired to form an armed group to overthrow the government of Rwanda, but Human Rights Watch and many others called the charges politically motivated and the European Parliament called for justice and said that the lower court had not met international judicial standards. I myself spoke to Victoire for Pacifica’s KPFA Radio-Berkeley many times in 2010 and I’ve never known anyone so opposed to armed conflict or committed to the rule of law.  Her conviction for this would be a howler if she weren’t facing another twelve years in prison and her family weren’t facing their fourth Christmas without her.

    Victoire speaks fluent Dutch, French, Kinyarwanda, and English, but pronounces “dialogue” and “debate” with a distinct and adamant French accent.  After the 2010 release of the UN Mapping Report documenting President Kagame’s army’s war crimes, crimes against humanity, and even genocide against Hutu refugees in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, she told KPFA that the mandate of the International Criminal Tribunal on Rwanda should be expanded to include crimes in Congo. Instead, she herself went to prison five days later.

    Other prisoners who testified to joining her in a conspiracy to form an armed group were granted release for time served on the same day her own conviction was upheld.  

    President Obama?   

    No one would seem to be more respectful of the West’s nominally revered democratic institutions and civil liberties than this Rwandan political prisoner, Victoire Ingabire, so why have President Obama and the U.S. State Department remained so silent about her case?  Neither President Obama nor British Prime Minister David Cameron hesitated to make it known that they had warned President Kagame not to send reinforcements across Rwanda’s western border to his M23 militia in the eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), when M23 finally faced defeat by the Congolese army and UN Force Intervention Brigade.  So why have they not, like the European Parliament, called on Rwanda, their longstanding ally and “military partner” to respect  judicial standards in Ingabire’s case?

    Victoire stands for negotiation with armed Rwandan refugees in Congo.” 

    Many reasons, no doubt, including former President Bill Clinton’s determination to protect his longtime friend Paul Kagame and their mutual determination to preserve the received history of the Rwandan Genocide and ensuing Congo wars and conflict.  Another may be Victoire’s opposition to their longstanding plan to make Rwanda, or at least its modern capital city Kigali, the “Singapore of Africa,” a banking, technology, and minerals processing hub and multinational corporate gateway to the resource riches of the DRC.  In 2010, during her thwarted attempt to run for president, Victoire said:  

    “The rural population in Rwanda has been neglected for the last 16 years and, instead of the Singapore model of development, which gives the lion’s share to a tiny, urban privileged elite, I would invest in agriculture, I would invest in rural roads and health networks. I would review the land management and I would give priority to the subsistence food crops, rather than cash crops which benefit mostly traders from urban areas. For example, if people cultivate only maize – if you ask them to cultivate only maize for export – what will they eat? This is why I will give priority to enough food to my people.”

    Like Tanzanian President Jacaya Kikwete, Victoire stands for negotiation with armed Rwandan refugees in Congo, who have been the Kagame regime’s excuse for invading and plundering that country for years.  

    “Victoire Ingabire does not believe in invading the neighbors,” said Rwanda Genocide survivor and Friends of the Congo activist Claude Gatebuke.   “So Victoire’s case is very significant, not only for Rwanda, but also for Congo.  If Victoire Ingabire were allowed to run for president in Rwanda, and she won, there would be a major change in how Rwandans and Congolese live as neighbors, because that would be the end of Rwanda invading Congo.”

    Imagine that.  After almost 20 years, and millions of Congolese and Rwandan refugees dead.

     Speech crime 

    The lower court also upheld Victoire Ingabire’s conviction for several speech crimes.

    1) “Spreading false rumors” intended to incite the public to rise up against the state.  
    Enough said, I hope, for anyone who believes in free speech.  Or anyone who understands that Rwanda is an authoritarian spy state that has engaged in a war of aggression in neighboring Congo for nearly 20 years.

    2)  “Minimizing” the 1994 Rwandan Genocide.  

    In 2010, Victoire went to the Kigali Genocide Memorial Centre, and said that Hutu as well as Tutsi victims should be remembered there.  The history of the Rwandan Genocide, codified in Rwanda’s Constitution, is that it was only Hutu extremists’ “Genocide Against the Tutsi.” 

    Before she went to prison, Victoire told KPFA listeners,“ My party and I have never denied the genocide, by the UN understanding, because the Resolution 955 from UN says that in Rwanda was genocide against the people of Rwanda . . . there was genocide against Tutsis and moderate Hutus. We don't have to forget that. Yes, there was genocide and all people involved should be brought to the court. But, before, during, and after the genocide, other Rwandese people were killed. Hutus and Tutsis were killed. Is this denying genocide? I don't feel so.”

    It’s difficult to rationally argue with this, because the 1991 Rwandan census, as documented by Ed Herman and David Peterson in The Politics of Genocide, reported a Rwandan population of 7,590,235, including 645,170 Tutsis, more than 300,000 fewer than the million Tutsis commonly reported to have died in the genocide.  And because Ibuka, Rwanda’s Tutsi genocide survivors group, has claimed that some 300,000 of these 645,170 Tutsis survived. President Kagame would therefore seem to have a lot of bones on display in his genocide memorial sites that he can’t properly account for as the result of his Constitutionally codified “Genocide Against the Tutsi.” 

    Rwanda is an authoritarian spy state that has engaged in a war of aggression in neighboring Congo for nearly 20 years.”

    Ever since I began to try to untangle this story, with my own focus on U.S. responsibility for backing the Kagame regime, Rwandan Hutu people have told me that they simply want to be able to bury and openly mourn their dead, that this is what they must do to heal and reconcile.  Others have told me that they want all the bones buried, not displayed in memorial museums, because it’s not normal in Rwanda to display the bones or body parts of the dead for tourists or anyone else.

    To many Rwandans, that is what Victoire Ingabire represents.  Acknowledging, remembering, mourning, and burying all the dead.

    Quite a few Rwandans appeared out of cyberspace to respond to my 2010 report,Rwanda’s packed prisons and genocide ideology law.  Some were absolutely furious, others deeply relieved, just because another writer in the U.S., which has been the dominant power in the region since the Rwanda Genocide and Congo Wars, was trying to make sense of this. At that point I realized how bitterly ethnically polarized Rwanda remains, despite the government's claim that ethnicity no longer exists there.  One reader who appreciated the report left this unforgettable statement in the comments section:

    “I am from Kiyombe in Byumba. RPF [Rwandan Patriotic Front] came in 1991 and called all the people from our village for a security meeting.  After people had gathered at the soccer pitch of Kiyombe, Mr. Hitler Kagame ordered his military to bomb the gathering. I escaped and went through the tea plantation and found my way to Uganda.  Ever since I have never returned to Rwanda but I am still considered a genocide denier or genocidaire.  Why? Simply because I am a Hutu and I don’t even have rights to go back to Rwanda and bury my family and relatives in dignity. Do you know how old I was then?  Just 16.  I survived but it is me and me alone.”

    After reading that, I turned to maps and found Kiyombe and Byumba, near the Ugandan border which the RPF, led by General Paul Kagame, had crossed in 1990.  And, which this young man then crossed all alone a year later, running in the other direction as a refugee. I also found the tea plantation that he said he had escaped through, and the tea processing plant nearby. 

    Ann Garrison is an independent journalist who contributes to the Black Star News, Counterpunch, Global Research, and the San Francisco Bay View Newspaper, and produces radio for KPFA-Berkeley and WBAI-New York City.  She can be reached on her website,, or at

    Share this

    -- [...]???????????? -

    [...]???????????? - ????????? ?????? ????????? ????????? ???????????????.[...]
    ### 칭찬합시다 - 사용안함 - 박종범 영산 회장님 많은 후원 감사드립니다!
    ...etcetera. - Catalog al afacerilor
    ::대학원 연구실 소개:: - 김윤희교수의 ë””ì§€í„¸í†µì‹ ì—°êµ¬ì‹¤ 소개
    [***] [***]
    [I Agree, Let Me Go!]
    11/3/2014 4:38
    12 Things You’re Doing Wrong on OKCupid
    2012년도 수치계산 게시판 - 수치컴퓨팅 및 응용 ìˆ™ì œ2 openGL포함 소스코드
    2013_winter mechmath - [중요] 이준상 교수님 홈페이지에서 서식 다운받으십시오.
    a podcast about sex
    ‘Pippi Longstocking’ Studio On Tami Erin Adult Picture
    adult performer Siri and International Mr. Leather follow-up
    Apsilankyti vartotojo tinklapyje
    Author\'s Website
    Bekijk de homepage
    Bekijk Webpagina
    Besøg brugerens webside
    Besøg Web siden
    Besøk innleggers hjemmeside
    Besøk Medlemmets Nettside
    Besök användarens hemsida
    Buy Real Cheap Facebook Likes
    Buy Vine Likes One Can Hire Providers To Get Help In Buying Facebook Likes
    chicago sex podcast
    chicago sex podcast -
    chicago sex podcast (not verified)
    chicago sex podcast’s avatar
    Chicago Sex Positive Podcast
    child porn
    child porn\'s Gravatar
    Clemmies Homepage besuchen
    Click here to visit this page
    Close this Frame.
    comedian and attending sex addict classes
    Content URL
    Сайт автора
    Посетить сайт автора
    Посетить Web Page автора
    Посетете сайта на потребителя
    괌여행팁 - 9ì›”10일부터 웨스틴 ìžìœ ì—¬í–‰ 상품을 이용시 ë¬´ë™ë ¥ í•´ì–‘ìŠ¤í¬ì¸ ê°€ 무료로...
    êµì œ > 사진첩 - 2014ë…„ 4ì›” 야외예배2 - 동명초등학교
    êµíšŒì¼ì • - 2013ë…„ 05ì›” 교회 주요행사 안내
    Ecampus -
    Eric Barry Chicago
    Eric Barry Chicago sex
    Eric Barry Chicago sex offender
    eric barry is gay
    Facebook\'s Black Market Problem Revealed - (4个脚印) (not verified) guy porn guy porn - guy porn (не проверено) guy porn (not verified) Says : sucks trackbacked on October 26, 2014, 11:41 am
    free porn
    free pussy
    free sex
    free xxx porn
    free xxx porn -
    free xxx porn(free xxx porn)
    Fugazi Full Disclosure Lyrics
    Full Disclosure
    Full Disclosure podcast
    Full Disclosure Podcast with Eric Barry
    Full Disclosure website
    Full Disclosure: Chicago\'s Sex Positive Podcast - Chica[...]
    Full Disclosure: Chicago\'s Sex Positive Podcast - Chicago-based podcast dedicated to sex positive news, interviews, and comedy with comedian and writer Eric Barry.
    Full Disclosure: Chicago\'s Sex Positive Podcast - Chicago-based podcast dedicated to sex positive news, interviews, and comedy with comedian and writer Eric Barry. - Backlinks on ParaKOSTer - []
    Getting Chance To Buy Facebook Likes Cheap
    Hendericks\'s homepage
    here you go
    Holy Porn Poachers - Superman! Axel Braun Shows Sues 098 Superman XXX Thieves - 7
    Home Page
    Home Page Home Page
    Homepage besuchen
    Homepage des Autors besuchen
    How Facebook Likes Get Bought And Sold
    How To Buy Facebook Likes With Cheapest Price
    How To Find Authentic Jobs Classifieds
    성경 Q&A - 대한민국 \"최초\" 프리미엄 릴 ㄱ ㅔ임 ì „ë¬¸ 싸 ã…‡ ㅣ트 릴넷
    Επίσκεψη στην ιστοσελίδα του Συγγραφέα
    한방상식 - 반만년 역사속의 민간요법이 다 과학-ì•„ëª¨ë ˆí¼ì‹œí”½ ê¸°ìˆ ì—°êµ¬ì› 한방과학팀 박준성(36) 연구원
    IL Sexual Predator
    is not accepting his apology
    Jwinpartners\' announces - [Announcement] Jwinpartner\'s 5th Anniversary
    Käy lähettäjän sivustolla
    Lesbo Retro Adult Retrospective Tonight At IXFF Film Fest In SF
    Link Anchor
    listen to the interview
    LiveCamNetwork Nets XBiz Nomination
    Longwell guy porn
    Miss Delaware Unfairly Outed By GirlsDoPorn aka Bubblegum Casting, A Shady Modeling Agency
    moment - 131125 tvN 制作发表会
    my sex-positive podcast called Full Disclosure
    Näytä web-sivu
    Naar website
    Nano-Photonics, KAIST - Baking 완료. SEM 사용재개
    notice - ★生日献礼★ 李东海29岁生日门板 3P
    انتقل الى صفحة المرسل
    صفحة الوب
    Odwied stron autora
    Odwiedź stronę autora
    ON 독서나눔방 - \'관계의 힘\'을 읽ê³
    Open website
    Página Principal
    Pastor Choi\'s Video Message - 2014.11.23 - 함께 나누며 감사하라(Thank the Lord with sharing)
    Persönliche Website von »NZachary« besuchen
    Persönliche Website von »PTVXR« besuchen
    photo - 140530 B.A.P 2014 L.O.E in Singapore Press Conference
    Podcast for young gay boys
    podcast host
    Pokaż stronę
    Positions Available - Immigration&Recruiting company looking Administrative manager
    Postati ofertele dvs. speciale aici 2009-09-28
    Pretty Emma Watson Pictures And Videos
    Read More
    Rough Sex Videos
    sex podcas
    sex podcast
    sex podcast chicago
    Sexual Openness
    Site web Site web
    Strona WWW
    Sunday Sermon - The Naming of 12 Apostles
    Teleteria has been the leader while in the
    The comments are worth reading - members of the leather community, including people who were in attendance, some of whom were working the event and dealt with Mr. Barry personally have much to say.
    Tips To Help You Buy Proper Facebook Likes
    Vaata liikme veebilehte
    Vedi la pagina Web
    Ver Página Web
    Ver Páxina Web
    Video And chatsex Chat ChatSex Shows!
    View Original
    View Web Page
    Visa WEB-sidan
    Visit Podcast Home Page
    Visit posters website
    Visit poster\'s website
    Visit Website
    Visita il mio sito
    Visita sito
    Visitar a homepage do Usuário
    Visitar a página do Utilizador
    Visitar a página na web do utilizador
    Visitar o website do usuário
    Visitar Site
    Visitar Sitio
    Visitar sitio web del autor
    Visiter la Page Web
    Visiter le site
    Visiter le site web de l\'utilisateur
    Visiter le site web du posteur
    Viziteaza site-ul autorului
    Vizitează site-ul autorului
    Vizualizare Pagina Web
    Web Site
    Weboldal megktekintése
    Website bekijken
    Website dieses Benutzers besuchen
    Webstranu posjetiti
    When Should I Buy Facebook Likes?
    Why DoN\'t You To Use A Free Webhost
    Why Schools Are BuyingXxx Web Addresses
    Why Universities Are BuyingXxx Web Addresses
    Worldwide Adult Legislation Could Boost British Sector (Wired UK)
    www.fdpod.… favicons
    xxx porn
    young teen sluts
    your company is still a business
    Zobraziť autorové WWW stránky
    Zobraziť autorove WWW stránky
    Zobrazit autorovi WWW stránky
    Zobrazit autorovy WWW stránky

    uji coba

    I most appreciating every

    I most appreciating every single of the information is actually incredible and decent impart. I must much obliged. Great blog, and have some extraordinary substance.
    obat kanker payudara

    Ginsneg RH2 terbuat dari

    Ginsneg RH2 terbuat dari ekstrak ginseng merah yang sangat langka keberadaannya. Sangat ampuh untuk mengatasi berbagai macam penyakit kanker, terutama penyakit kanker payudara. obat kanker payudara



    ACE MAXS Obat Kanker Hati , Obat Kanker Mulut , Obat Maag Akut , Obat Sakit Pinggang , Obat Kanker Pankreas , Obat Tumor Payudara , Yang Terbukti 100% Terbuat Dari Bahan-Bahan Herbal Hasil Alam INDONESIA.


    Gastric Health Tablet Merupakan Obat Maag Akut Tradisional Terbaik Terbukti Ampuh Obati Penyakit Maag Akut Secara Alami Dan Tanpa
    Efek Samping.


    Obat Ampuh Untuk Mengobati Penyakit Benjolan Di Kelopak Mata yaitu dengan Obat Benjolan Di Kelopak Mata ACE MAXS.

    Jack andrew

    Share Information...
    Obat Benjolan Di Ketiak Yang Ampuh, Manjur Serta Tanpa Efe Samping.
    Obat Abses Payudara Yang Ampuh, Manjur Serta Tanpa Efe Samping.
    ACE MAXS Obat Benjolan Di Kepala Yang Ampuh Tanpa Efek Samping
    ACE MAXS Obat Benjolan Di Tubuh Yang Ampuh Tanpa Efek Samping.

    Agen Resmi Obat ACE MAXS Tasikmalaya

    Selamat datang di Situs Agen Resmi ACE MAXS Tasikmalaya.Kami melayani pemesanan dan pembelian Ace Maxs ke seluruh wilayah Indonesia, Bekerjasama dengan Jasa Pengiriman JNE.untuk lebih jelasnya kunjungi website resmi kami di Cara Pemesanan Obat ACE MAXS.

    bring me

    Sharing Informations... Obat Sinusitis Tradisional 100% Terbuat Dari Bahan Alami, Ampuh, Manjur Serta Tanpa Efe Samping.


    to meet you

    Obat Kanker Kelenjar Getah Bening Stadium 4

    ACE MAXS Obat Kanker Kelenjar Getah Bening Stadium 4 Yang Terbukti 100% Terbuat Dari Bahan-Bahan Herbal Hasil Alam INDONESIA.

    Grosir ACE MAXS Plus

    Inilah ACE MAXS ObatVertigo , Obat Gula Darah Herbal , Obat Kanker Indung Telur , Obat kanker empedu , Obat Penurun Kolesterol Tinggi Yang terbuat dari 100% bahan-bahan herbal hasil alam INDONESIA.

    gOld Burry

    Khasiat ACE MAXS sebagai : Obat Kanker Paru-Paru , Obat Kanker Usus , Obat Komplikasi Jantung, Diabetes , Ginjal, Asam Urat , Obat Radang Panggul , Obat Osteoporosis 100% Terbukti Ampuh atasi penyakit sampai tuntas.

    ACE MAXS Plus Terbaik

    ACE MAXS berkhasiat sebagai Obat Sakit Pinggang Tradisional , Obat Penyakit Gondok , Obat Hipertiroid Herbal , Obat Kanker Pankreas , Obat Kelenjar Getah Bening Di
    100% Terbuat dari bahan herbal Yang Ampuh Tanpa Efek Samping.


    Obat Ampuh Untuk Mengobati Penyakit Benjolan Di Kelopak Mata yaitu dengan Obat Benjolan Di Kelopak Mata ACE MAXS.

    tegarkan hatiku ya rabb

    Kami rekomendasikan kepada anda Obat Kelenjar Getah Bening Di Leher Yang Ampuh, Aman, Alami dan tanpa efek samping.

    bruno mars

    ACE MAXS Obat Kanker Kelenjar Getah Bening Stadium 4 Yang Terbukti 100% Terbuat Dari Bahan-Bahan Herbal Hasil Alam INDONESIA.


    Inilah ACE MAXS Obat Vertigo Yang Ampuh dan aman.

    Gula Darah

    Hanyalah ACE MAXS Obat Gula Darah Yang Tanpa Efek Samping dan efektif.

    kolesterol tinggi

    This website very gooddd sir... Obat Penurun Kolesterol Tinggi

    kanker usus

    Inform.. Obat Kanker Usus nice brother...


    Obat Osteoporosis 100% Terbukti Ampuh atasi OSTEOPOROSIS sampai tuntas.

    Agen Resmi ACE MAXS Tasikmalaya

    Kami Ucapkan Selamat Datang di Website Agen Resmi ACE MAXS Tasikmalaya , Sebagai penyedia obat herbal terbesar , terlengkap, dengan kualitas terbaik.


    Nice for all article

    Nice Obat Benjolan Di Kelopak Mata all rights...

    excuse me


    thats right for all article... Obat Benjolan Di Perut yang ampuh dan tanpa efek samping.

    kanker otak stadium 4

    john continues to be the face, as well as voice, of his company, but admits that success did not come overnight. Obat Kanker Otak Stadium 4 At first, Schnatter struggled to expand his business.

    Impotensi Karena Diabetes

    Excuse me for share Obat Impotensi Karena DiabetesYang Ampuh Dan Manjur


    Excuse me for share Obat Benjolan Di Tubuh Yang Ampuh.