Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.  If you broadcast our audio commentaries please consider a recurring donation to Black Agenda Report.

This Isn’t Reform, It’s Robbery

  • Sharebar
    Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version
    no reform hereby Chris Hedges
    The debate over health care “reform” has devolved to a frenzied assault on the U.S. Treasury, abetted by corporate enablers in both parties. “The proposed plans rattling around Congress all ensure that the profits for these corporations will increase and the misery for ordinary Americans will be compounded.” With Capitol Hill consumed in corruption, direct citizen action is the only avenue available.
    This Isn’t Reform, It’s Robbery
    by Chris Hedges
    This article originally appeared in Truthdig.
    Percentage change since 2002 in average premiums paid to large US health-insurance companies: +87%
    Percentage change in the profits of the top ten insurance companies: +428%
    Chances that an American bankrupted by medical bills has health insurance: 7 in 10
    —Harper’s Index, September 2009
    “And any debate about health care must acknowledge that the for-profit health care industry is the problem and must be destroyed.”
    Capitalists, as my friend Father Michael Doyle says, should never be allowed near a health care system. They hold sick children hostage as they force parents to bankrupt themselves in the desperate scramble to pay for medical care. The sick do not have a choice. Medical care is not a consumable good. We can choose to buy a used car or a new car, shop at a boutique or a thrift store, but there is no choice between illness and health. And any debate about health care must acknowledge that the for-profit health care industry is the problem and must be destroyed. This is an industry that hires doctors and analysts to deny care to patients in order to increase profits. It is an industry that causes half of all bankruptcies. And the 20,000 Americans who died last year because they did not receive adequate care condemn these corporations as complicit in murder.
    The current health care debate in Congress has nothing to do with death panels or public options or socialized medicine. The real debate, the only one that counts, is how much money our blood-sucking insurance, pharmaceutical and for-profit health services are going to be able to siphon off from new health care legislation. The proposed plans rattling around Congress all ensure that the profits for these corporations will increase and the misery for ordinary Americans will be compounded. The corporate state, enabled by both Democrats and Republicans, is yet again cannibalizing the Treasury. It is yet again pushing Americans, especially the poor and the working class, into levels of despair and rage that will continue to fuel the violent, proto-fascist movements leaping up around the edges of American society. And the traditional watchdogs—those in public office, the press and citizens groups—are as useless as the perfumed fops of another era who busied their days with court intrigue at Versailles. Canada never looked so good.
    “The corporate state, enabled by both Democrats and Republicans, is yet again cannibalizing the Treasury.”
    The Democrats are collaborating with lobbyists for the insurance industry, the pharmaceutical industry and for-profit health care providers to craft the current health care reform legislation. “Corporate and industry players are inside the tent this time,” says David Merritt, project director at Newt Gingrich’s Center for Health Transformation, “so there is a vacuum on the outside.” And these lobbyists have already killed a viable public option and made sure nothing in the bills will impede their growing profits and capacity for abuse.
    “It will basically be a government law that says you have to buy their defective product,” says Dr. David Himmelstein, a professor at Harvard Medical School and a founder of Physicians for a National Health Plan. “Next the government will tell us a Pinto in every garage, a lead-coated toy to every child and melamine-laced puppy chow for every dog.”
    “Health insurance is not a race to the top; it is a race to the bottom,” he told me from Cambridge, Mass. “The way you make money is by abusing people. And if a public-option plan is not ready and willing to abuse patients it is stuck with the expensive patients. The premiums will go up until it is noncompetitive. The conditions that have now been set for the plans include a hobbled public option. Under the best-case scenario there will be tens of millions [who] will remain uninsured at the outset, and the number will climb as more and more people are priced out of the insurance market.”
    “The way you make money is by abusing people.”
    The inclusion of these corporations in the crafting of health care legislation has not stopped figures like Rick Scott, the former head of the Columbia/HCA health care company, from attempting to sabotage any plan. Scott’s company was forced to pay a $1.7 billion fraud settlement—the largest health care fraud settlement in U.S. history—for stealing hundreds of millions from taxpayers by overbilling for medical care. Scott, who made his money primarily from Medicare, is now saturating the airwaves in a reputed $20 million ad campaign that is stoking the anger and fear of many Americans. His ads are coordinated by CRC Public Relations, the group that masterminded the “Swift boat”attacks against 2004 Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry.
    “They are using our money to campaign against us,” Dr. Himmelstein told me. “The money for these commercials came from health care interests that collect fees from American patients. We experienced this before in Massachusetts. We ran a ballot initiative for universal health care in 2000 and the insurance industry spent $5 million on it, including the insurance company I am insured by. They used my premiums to smear an idea that 70 percent in Massachusetts, according to polls, favored before this smear campaign. Universal health care was narrowly defeated.”
    The bills now in Congress will, at best, impose on the country the failed model in Massachusetts. That model will demand that Americans buy health insurance from private insurers. There will be some subsidies for the very poor but not for anyone above a modest income. Insurers will be allowed to continue to jack up premiums, including for the elderly. The bankruptcies due to medical bills and swelling premiums will mount along with rising deductibles and co-payments. Health care will be beyond the reach of many families. In Massachusetts one in six people who have mandated insurance still say they cannot afford care, and 30,000 people were evicted from the state program this month because of budget cuts. Expect the same debacle nationwide.
    “The bankruptcies due to medical bills and swelling premiums will mount along with rising deductibles and co-payments.”
    “For someone my age who is making $40,000 a year you are required to lay out $5,000 for an insurance premium for coverage that covers nothing until you have spent $2,000 out of pocket,” Himmelstein said. “You are $7,000 out of pocket before you have any coverage at all. For most people that means you are already bankrupt before you have insurance. If anything, that has made them worse off.  Instead of having that $5,000 to cover some of their medical expenses they have laid it out in premiums.”
    The U.S. spends twice as much as other industrialized nations on health care—$7,129 per capita—although 45.7 million Americans remain without health coverage and millions more are inadequately covered. There are 14,000 Americans a day now losing their health coverage. A report in the journal Health Affairs estimates that, if the system is left unchanged, one of every five dollars spent by Americans in 2017 will go to health coverage. Private insurance bureaucracy and paperwork consume one-third, 31 percent, of every health care dollar. Streamlining payment through a single nonprofit payer would save more than $400 billion per year, enough, Physicians for a National Health Plan points out, to provide comprehensive, high-quality coverage for all Americans. But the proposed America’s Affordable Health Choices Act of 2009 (H.R. 3200 in the House) will, rather than cut costs, add an estimated $239 billion over 10 years to the federal deficit. This is very good for the corporations. It is very bad for us.
    The lobbyists have, as they did with the obscene bailouts for banks and investment firms, hijacked legislation in order to fleece the citizen. The five largest private health insurers and their trade group, America’s Health Insurance Plans, spent more than $6 million on lobbying in the first quarter of 2009. Pfizer, the world’s biggest drug maker, spent more than $9 million during the last quarter of 2008 and the first three months of this year. The Washington Post reported that up to 30 members of Congress from both parties who hold key committee memberships have major investments in health care companies totaling between $11 million and $27 million. President Barack Obama’s director of health care policy, who will not discuss single-payer as an option, has served on the boards of several health care corporations.
    “The press treats single-payer as a fringe movement.”
    Obama and the congressional leadership have shut out advocates of single-payer. The press, including papers such as The New York Times, treats single-payer as a fringe movement.The television networks rarely mention it. And yet between 45 and 60 percent of doctors favor single-payer. Between 40 and 62 percent of the American people, including 80 percent of registered Democrats, want universal, single-payer not-for-profit health care for all Americans. The ability of the corporations to discredit and silence voices that represent at least half of the population is another sad testament to the power of our corporate state.
    “We are considering a variety of striking efforts for early in the fall,” Dr. Himmelstein said, “including protests outside state capitals by doctors around the country, video links of conferences in 70 or 80 cities around the country, with protests and potential doctors chaining themselves to the fence of the White House.”
    Make sure you join them.
    Copyright © 2009 Truthdig, L.L.C.

      

    Share this

    Health Care and Death Panels

    Thanks Mr. Hodges for dropping some truth amidst all of the half truths and out right lies.  Any health plan other than single payer is the same ole bull sh*t we have now just warmed over.  As long as the for profit insurance pharmaceutical and hospitals are allowed to be any part of our health care system we really do not have health care.
     
    It is utterly amazing how single pay was allowed to be kicked off the table out of the room and out of consideration.  In its place was put a jug of kool aide called the public option.  This Frankenstein concoction has been crafted by the insurance companies with so called bi-partition help from The Gang of Six.  The Gang of Six you say, just when did street gangs come to be involved in out health care matters???  Whoa Nelle we not talkin bout the thugs on your block or in your hood.  We are talkin bout the REAL Gangstas, the ones in Congress.  Yep Yep Yep them Gangtas.  The big ballers of this crew are as follows; Sen. Max Baucus (D-MT) Sen. Jeff Bingaman (D-NM) Sen. Kent Conrad (D-ND) Sen. Mike Enzi (R-WY) Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA) Sen. Olympia Snowe (R-ME).  Just look at the states that they represent Montana, New Mexico, North Dakota, Wyoming, Iowa and Maine.  Now that is where the REAL (Code Speak) Americans have REAL health care issues.  This wrecking crew has been running interference for the health industry.  Here is a link to just how much money the health industry has P-A-I-D them to bum rush any health care plan that is not based on the for profit system we now have. http://act.credoaction.com/campaign/gang_of_6/
     
    How dumb are we as a nation???  How is it that a whole nation can be conned into being against something that is in their own best interest???  Is Bill Maher correct, are we that S-T-U-P-I-D???  There has been a lot of talk about death panels lately but the only REAL Death Panels are the ones that the insurance companies have.  It is the insurance companies that make LIFE and DEATH decisions concerning our health.  They are the ones who by rescission (finding some technicality to cancel a policy) or just straight out denial/refusal to cover some operation care or procedure.  Those kinds of decisions by Insurance Companies have Life and Death consequences for people.  People who have been paying premiums for years get sick and expect that their insurance company will pay for some or all of the medical bills only to have their policy canceled or be refused some operation care or procedure and left to go bankrupt trying to pay for it themselves or worse DIE!!!  And we are not even going to talk about the folks that have no insurance at all.
     
    Now if you are from that “we can keep what we've got if we like it” or the “No one will take your health insurance bennies away” crowd.  Here is a news flash for you follow this link to read and weep http://www.smirkingchimp.com/thread/23515 seems that logic is fatally flawed too.
     
    And if you are one of those who think that government run health care will ration care follow this link and read in black and white how the for profit health industrial complex handles health care http://www.smirkingchimp.com/thread/23521 I thought you knew!!!
     
    The medial industrial complex has used projection to frame this monologue on health care.  They have projected what they (health care industry) actually DO (cancel policies make life and death decisions IE death panels) onto the public option kool aide so as to cripple it to the point where it is absolutely useless (if it wasn’t already useless from the start).  The public option was weak from the get go they just want to make sure that it is DOA.  The Gang of Six have been working like little beavers to train wreck any conversation about any alternative plan IE Single Payer.  With this Death Duo (the insurance companies and the Gang of Six) wheelin and dealin any hope for real health care plan is unthinkable.
     
    I have said this repeatedly they want us all reduced to the lowest common denominator DIRT POOR DIRT IGNORANT and DIRT HEALTHY.  Can you hear me NOW???  The Wall Street ponzi catastrophe and the subsequent bailout, stick up, heist rape pillage and plunder (take your pick).of the treasury has us all DIRT POOR.  The non stop blizzard of half truths hypocrisy and bold face lies coupled with our apparent stupor of senselessness will keep us DIRT IGNORANT and the scorn ridicule and subversion of anything that would resemble a functioning health care system will keep us DIRT HEALTHLY…Holy guacamole Batman I think I am going to be sick!!!
     
     
    Peace
     
     
    S Murph
     

    Discount Christian Louboutin

    This Christian Louboutin New Decoltissimo Pointed Pump will surely complete a very feminine look since black is commonly associated with women. Discount Christian Louboutin For Sale. This will also put you in the trend of today's black colored hue just in time for the spring season, keeping your every ensemble in style.Where to buy Cheap Christian Louboutin boots? Where to buy the super-fashion Christian Louboutin pumps ? Come to www.christianlouboutinshoes88.com. You can find the Fahison Christian Louboutin Shoes here.Buy Christian Louboutin Ariella studded boots online store.

    Ed hardy clothing

    Ed Hardy Online Shop offering Ed hardy clothing to you vintage tattoo inspired fashion and lifestyle for men, women, and children. And we offer many kinds of brand Fashion Coach handbags,Rolex watches,Replica handbags. Welcome to my website,we can offer best 24/7 service.

    Replica handbags

    Best replica shop online is proud Replica handbags, such as Replica shoes,Replica Gucci,Replica Chanel,Replica Louis Vuitton from our Replica handbags store.Our Replica handbags Catalog is packed with the dream replica handbags you deserve in www.lv138.com. Fashion Fake handbags and other designer Replica handbags wholesale. As the handbags become a standard part of most people's wardrobe.

    Upcoming Single Payer Actions in NYC

    http://is.gd/2ADXQ

    8.27.09 NYC (Single-Payer) Whole Foods Boycott Action http://is.gd/2AG0s
    8.29.09 NYC March FOR Single-Payer! http://is.gd/2ADAq

    Clicky Web Analytics